As the tracking is now up to 83 awards we start to get a clearer picture. Three games are basically in the real competition, and Baldur's Gate pulled away among them with 45 awards (more than half of all), Zelda has 20, Alan Wake has 13. By now a lot of games have one award each: Disney Illusion Island, Spiderman 2, Octopath 2, Super Mario Wonder and Sea of Stars. As last year the site tracked nearly 600 awards it is too early to call it for BG3, but it starts to look that way.
https://goty.gamefa.com/year/2023/