| Rank | Title | Platform(s) | Developer | Year |
| #50 | The Legend of Zelda: Link’s Awakening | Game Boy Color | Nintendo | 1998 |
| #49 | Star Wars Battlefront II | PS2 | Pandemic Studios | 2005 |
| #48 | Just Cause 2 | PC | Avalanche Studios | 2010 |
| #47 | Hitman: Blood Money | PC | IO Interactive | 2006 |
| #46 | Dishonored | PC | Arkane Studios | 2012 |
| #45 | Mass Effect | PC | BioWare | 2007 |
| #44 | God of War | PS2 | Santa Monica Studio | 2005 |
| #43 | DOOM | PC | id Software | 2016 |
| #42 | Hotline Miami | PC | Dennaton Games | 2012 |
| #41 | Ratchet & Clank | PS4 | Insomniac Games | 2016 |
| #40 | Middle Earth: Shadow of Mordor | PC | Monolith Productions | 2014 |
| #39 | Braid | PS3 | Number None | 2008 |
| #38 | Age of Empires II: The Age of Kings | PC | Ensemble Studios | 1999 |
| #37 | Ratchet & Clank: A Crack in Time | PS3 | Insomniac Games | 2009 |
| #36 | The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion | PS3 | Bethesda Softworks | 2006 |
| #35 | XCOM 2 | PC | Firaxis Games | 2016 |
| #34 | Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain | PC | Kojima Productions | 2015 |
| #33 | Batman: Arkham City | PS3 | Rocksteady Studios | 2011 |
| #32 | Grand Theft Auto V | PS3 | Rockstar North | 2013 |
| #31 | Red Dead Redemption | PS3 | Rockstar San Diego | 2010 |
| #30 | Age of Mythology | PC | Ensemble Studios | 2002 |
| #29 | Populous: The Beginning | PC | Bullfrog Games | 1999 |
| #28 | Civilization V | PC | Firaxis | 2010 |
| #27 | Doom Eternal | PC | id Software | 2020 |
| #26 | Bloodborne | PS4 | From Software | 2015 |
| #25 |
Crusader Kings 3 |
PC |
Paradox |
2020 |
| #24 |
Assassin's Creed: Odyssey |
PS4 |
Ubisoft |
2018 |
| #23 |
Spiderman |
PS4 |
Insomniac |
2018 |
| #22 |
Far Cry 3 |
PC |
Ubisoft |
2012 |
| #21 |
God of War III |
PS3 |
Santa Monica |
2010 |
| #20 |
Uncharted 2: Among Thieves |
PS3 |
Naughty Dog |
2009 |
| #19 |
Uncharted 4: A Thief's End |
PS4 |
Naughty Dog |
2016 |
| #18 |
The Last of Us |
PS3 |
Naughty Dog |
2013 |
| #17 |
Assassin’s Creed II |
PS3 |
Ubisoft |
2009 |
| #16 |
Warcraft III: Reign of Chaos |
PC |
Blizzard |
2002 |
| #15 |
Mass Effect 2 |
PC |
BioWare |
2010 |
| #14 |
Splinter Cell: Chaos Theory |
PS2 |
Ubisoft |
2005 |
| #13 |
Mass Effect 3 |
PC |
BioWare |
2012 |
| #12 |
Ratchet & Clank: Up Your Arsenal |
PS2 |
Insomniac |
2004 |
| #11 |
God of War II |
PS2 |
Santa Monica |
2007 |
| #10 |
Portal 2 |
PC |
Valve |
2011 |
| #9 |
The Last of Us Part II |
PS4 |
Naughty Dog |
2020 |
| #8 |
Horizon: Zero Dawn |
PS4 |
Guerilla |
2017 |
| #7 |
God of War |
PS4 |
Santa Monica |
2018 |
| #6 |
BioShock |
PS3 |
2K |
2007 |
| #5 |
BioShock Infinite |
PC |
Irrational |
2013 |
| #4 |
Shadow of the Colossus |
PS2 |
Team Ico |
2004 |
| #3 |
The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim |
PC |
Bethesda |
2011 |
| #2 |
Divinity: Original Sin 2 |
PC |
Larian |
2017 |
| #1 |
The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt |
PC |
CD Projekt |
2015 |
(Former) Lead Moderator and (Eternal) VGC Detective 
