MetaScore ain't perfect, but the cumulative rating system is a much better indicator about the quality of games than the ratings of single persons. Extreme opinions get balanced out in most cases.
"Babyz DS" doesn't even have a MetaScore and Mafia II had a score of 74 - 77 (depending on the version)... so WTF are you talking about?
And you are free to write down a list of Wii games that are hidden gems.
Thanks for the laugh tho.
Was talking about this as one example. An example as one piece in a larger problem that expands past one website.
So it is a rating of a single person and NOT a meta-rating.
Only strenghens my argument that a cumulative rating system out of many ratings is a much better indicator about the quality of games.
And where is the huge list of hidden Wii gems?