By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

The Last Jedi was a very good film in my opinion, better than The Force Awakens, although I liked that too, and better than the prequel trilogy as well. As far as the complains I've heard, Luke had always been a character who overcorrected on his mistakes and acted on instinct, so him becoming despondent over his failure to recreate the Jedi order seems perfectly in line with how he always was.

As for Rey being a Mary Sue, not even close. Being a Mary Sue is not just about having power or abilites, but being perfect and not having a clear personality and flaws, and Rey is not even close to being that. She's overeager, slef-absorbed, shortsighter refuses to acknowledge her own past despite seemingly having always known deep down about her past, acts without thinking things through, and even hates herself and her origin to a certain extent.