By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
S.T.A.G.E. said:
Emperorbach said:
urgghh the defence here is silly , ninthys practices are old outdated and actually illegal , since this is under fair use protection
.........gamers need to realiise their fave companies can mess up and can do better

Fair use doesn't  mean anything to nintendo. Their Nintendo youtube  program is a testament to that.


There is currently no legislation on whether Lets Plays fall under Fair Use and as such, Nintendo is not doing anything illegal. There have been zero links provided to instances in which Nintendo submitted a copyright claim against a news/review video despite my multiple requests. Youtube's flawed Content ID system (which is distinct from copyright claims) is the cause of false removal of certain videos, but that is more or less out of Nintendo's hands unless they choose to give free reign.

This policy is not a violation of fair use under the current precedent.