EDGE gives Yoshi's New Island 4/10 [62 on Metacritic]

[AZWification]

forest-spirit said:

AZWification said:

I wasn't expecting some egg-celent reviews, but I wasn't expecting this mediocre score either. Sure, the art style looked weird ever since the first trailer came out and the level design didn't look like anything special, but I wasn't egg-specting less than 70. Oh well.

Not only once, but twice, and in the same post. No dessert for you young man.

 

OT: Not surprised by the average reviews. Nothing I've seen has screamed 'Masterpiece' to me. I'm still going to get it, it's just not top-priority.

Oh man.. I thought you were a good egg. :(