Your favorite role playing Mario game of all time

[AZWification]

domflo said:

AZWification said:

domflo said:
They're all excellent, except for 2, which are merely "quite good": Super Mario RPG and Sticker Star.
Though I find it hard to classify Sticker Star as an RPG, to be honest.
Favourite would be Paper Mario: The Thousand Year Door, followed by Mario and Luigi: SuperStar Saga and then all the others, though I really can't come up with a concrete ranking.

So, in short:
PM:TTYD>M&L:SS>M&L:PIT/M&L:BIS/M&L:DTB/PM/SPM>>>SMRPG(/PM:SS)

Paper Mario: The Thousand Year Door also happens to be my favourite game of all time.

   Sorry, dude, but Mario RPG is WAY better than Sticker Star..  Music is better,  characters are better ( Bowser barely even speaks in Sticker Star), battles are more entertaining, there are  more secrets and optional things to do like the casino,  Super Suit, Attack Scarf, the Culex fight, Jinx, etc...

SMRPG felt so "un-Mario" to me. Maybe has something to do with Squaresoft doing the game, but I don't really know. As an RPG, SMRPG is superior to Sticker Star, but that's only because I don't think of Sticker Star as an RPG to begin with. In the end, looking back at my time with both games, they were both quite good and I both enjoyed them just the same, which is why I put them in the same category. One might as well be better as the other, but that opinion changes so frequently in my mind (I can't, for example, decide if I like Mario&Luigi: Bowsers Inside Story or Super Paper Mario more: One day I'll say SPM, the other it'll be Bowsers Inside Story) that I don't want to list them in concrete order. It's just that I think of both as "quite good" games.

        Maybe because Square worked on it  along with Nintendo back in the day? it is still a good game to me.