By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
tbone51 on 29 October 2013
Edit Thread
Lawlight said:
tbone51 said:
Lawlight said:



2 things

1. You disappeared wen you were so sure pokemon XY wouldn't sell well. You kept saying it would have bad sales in every Pre order US thread!

2. BW is not a fair comparison, DP is. If GTA 6 came out in 4 years it would not be nowhere near comparable to GTA5 cuz it has over 160mil user base. Same with Pokemon BW and Pokemon XY

another thing you dont notice is the legs, BW exploded the highest out of all pokemon games but out of the 5 it is the least sold lifetime. XY is ahead of DP by a good margin. Your 11 or was it 12mil prediction will get shattered! 

Pls now explain sales dropping to me this early with 140mil user base vs 35mil user base


1. No, I was around. Remember when you thought Pokemon X/Y sold 5.5M in 1 day? I did say that was too high.

2. That 1/3rd of the people voting in the poll to say that Pokemon would outsell GTAV.

And I was talking about sales drop from B&W to X/Y. Not sure why you don't think they are good comparisons. If anything, it'sa favorable to compare X/Y to B&W since it sold less than Pearl/Something.

1.You werent there when numbers came up, the 5.5mil might be too high but you still thought it sell bad. over 3mil is great sales Day 1

2. The poll is BS, everybody votes for wat they dream of. It only matters who posted it. only like 2 or 3 peoplle though that and thats not really on topic lol!

Your last statement i dont think you get at all. Its not a good comparison. Its not favorable to compare bw with xy. If it is look up DP sales vs BW. DP got destroyed by BW sales First year right? but it outsold it. XY is comparable to DP cuz both went on the handheld on its 3rd year, BW did on DS final years! I dont kno why you dont understand? That means every Vita game is doing bad that had a psp version cuz its down sales by hundreds of thousands or millions!