What deserves GoTY on VGA

[sundin13]

Torillian said:

All things being equal you'd have to give ThatGameCompany the same budget as every other title and then see who makes the best game.  Why does equal ground only factor in on the back end? 

Because then we would be arguing hypotheticals and that makes even less sense. On the footing they are on now, they are not equal

 

@green_sky: Your argument doesn't make sense. It has nothing to do with how much the game sold or how much money it makes. using the movie analogy (that ive used a few times already) its like comparing short films to feature films. They arent in the same category because they are just not on even ground. It doesnt make sense to compare the two and it doesn't make sense to give a 10min film a movie of the year award when it is competing with 2 hour films.