Which will give a bigger HW boost: Xillia or Gears?

[smroadkill15]

wilco said:

smroadkill15 said:

Lord_Yggdrassil said:
Xilia. ,most who wants gears has a 360. The boost will be very small.

People said the same thing about Halo: Reach and look the huge boost it gave. 

To be fair, the new xbox model had just come out when halo reach was released.

Ya about 3 months earlier. The 360 was still riding the boost from the slim model when Reach released and added about another 100k doing about 250k that week. I still remember people saying Reach wouldn't move any HW because most people that wanted Reach had a 360 already. I'm not saying Gears 3 will move HW like Reach did, but it sure as hell will move about 50-100k extra for that week.