The Uncharted 3 OVER Battlefield 3(X360) CLUB!!! Update 12 sept.

[fauzman]

Mordred11 said:

fauzman said:

Jay520 said:
First Week: Battlefield 3 definitely. Bad Company had a pretty high first week. Battlefield 3's FW will likely be higher due to more pre-orders

First 10 weeks: Depends.

It all depends on the quality of the games. Will Battlefield be the COD killer that EA Wants? or will casuals just see it as another Medal of Honor? Will Uncharted 3's multiplayer be the CoD-killer that Naughty Dog wants? Will it take the industry by storm like Uncharted 2 did? These unknowns will play a large factor in which has a higher first 10 weeks.

I guess Battlefield 3 because it will have a rather large opening & hype.

Lifetime: Most likely Uncharted 3. Past Battlefields have had poor legs.

Ditto. U3 will take it in the end.

So you also think that for the 10 first weeks,Battlefield 3 will take it?

Kinda tricky. BF3 is doing better in US (on preorders) and i suspect UC3 will do better in EMEAA, but yeah, i suspect BF3 will have the higher sales initially (though i hope UC3 will surprise me and get a surge in the final few weeks before launch).