Would you count these games as a sucess or a failure- Wii Edition

[Conegamer]

jarrod said:

Conegamer said:

Machina said:

After a quick scan of the titles and their sales, these are my initial reactions:

Xenoblade - meh
MH3 - success
RS2 - failure
Other M - failure
Boom Blox -  success

This seems to be the general trend, and what I expected. Nice one

Yeah, more or less.  I think more context would help though, Other M's more sluggish but it'll still do decent numbers compared to most similar games (especially on Wii).  Boom Blox was an eventual success, but it basically flopped up front and only crawled to decent figures over the long haul.  The only unqualified success there is MH3 imo, and the only unqualified failure is RS2.

Remember, this is my FIRST EVER THREAD- lay off :)

ANYWAY, yeah I agree. Other M would be a success if we only looked at America, and Tri would be a failure if we only looked at the UK. It depends on your views. Perhaps if we leave other M for another few weeks we'll pick up on legs. As for the rest, well, we'll have to wait for Christmas really, see if those new Ninty ads have the desired affect. I bet they won't :P

EDIT**

How can you call Boom Blox a flop? That's like calling NSMBWii a failure because it doesn't have a 100% attach rate...