Kantor on 12 December 2009
I say it's a perfectly good list. Of course, opinions differ, but I wouldn't say any of those games don't deserve to be nominees.
Though inFamous and Demon's Souls deserve it too, I suppose. Between those seven, you can't go wrong with any 5 (unless you miss out Uncharted 2).
(Former) Lead Moderator and (Eternal) VGC Detective 
