God of War III vs. Uncharted 2 sales

[Kantor]

OctaBech said:

Kantor said:

OctaBech said:

Kantor said:

riecsou said:
GOW III will be release in the same month than FF XIII. So sales should be interesting.

Why? One is a JRPG, one is a hack and slash.

Don't call GoW hack n slash, it's more like an adventure(not Sam n Max but Indiana Jones(films)) game.

Just because the franchise does fighting very well it's not the core of the games.

Yes, it is.

The majority of the game is spent fighting. There's a little bit of platforming thrown in. It's too...one dimensional (in movement space, not gameplay) to be considered an Adventure, I think.

It's like DMC, or Ninja Gaiden. But, of course, made with very different values, being a Western game.

No, God of War is about the setpieces and traversal, that the combat turned out to be great is luck.

Setpieces? You mean quick time events? There are a fair few of those, and God of War actually manages to implement them well, unlike every other game ever.

As for traversal, not really. Kill enemies, walk to next room, kill enemies, climb wall, kill boss, kill enemies, puzzle, walk to next room, kill enemies, repeat.

The God of War games are very linear. GoW2 is clearer in my mind, and I can remember everything up to arrival on the Island of Creation being about traversal (except Rhodes), but the focus during the rest of the game was definitely on the combat.

On second thought, I suppose it is more of a Hack and Slash/Adventure hybrid. Perhaps that's why I prefer it to other hack and slash, like Ninja Gaiden which is literally kill enemies, walk to next room, fancy platforming segment, enemies, boss, repeat.