Will NSMB Wii will be GOTY of 2009? PSSIBLE?

[Kantor]

RolStoppable said:

Kantor said:
You're comparing it to Super Mario Galaxy? The same Super Mario Galaxy with a 97 on Metacritic? The same SMG which is the second highest rated game of all time on GameRankings?

I don't think anyone was surprised by that.

As for NSMBWii, highly unlikely. Firstly, it's in 2D and doesn't really reinvent anything, the way SMG did. Secondly, giving GoTY to 2 Mario games in 3 years would be a little off.

Why would it be off, if the games just so happen to be the best of the year?

Or would you be upset, if most gaming websites would agree that PS3's game of the year was Uncharted (2) in 2007 and 2009?

The thing is, they didn't. CoD4 got the majority of HD awards. More importantly, we have no idea if NSMBWii is as good as SMG, so we can't decide until we know that.