Well, here's my two cents.
The platforming was brilliant. The death system was perfectly implemented for the platforming. Brilliant.
The soundtrack was, again, brilliant.
The graphics were very well done.
The voice acting was a little annoying in that these two Middle Eastern people were speaking in American accents, but it was still good, unlike a certain "Assassin's Creed"
It was repetitive, but not as repetitive as Assassin. The environments were varied, but I just wanted a bit more depth.
I am in the minority that thought the combat worked very well, but seriously Ubisoft, stop holding our hands here. If we die, make us restart the fight. We'll hate you for now, but like you more in the long term.
I'd give it 8.8/10. Solid game, needed a few improvements. Better than Warrior Within (obviously), not as good as Sands of Time or The Two Thrones.
(Former) Lead Moderator and (Eternal) VGC Detective 
