so your argument that it is a good game is because it takes away from traditional core group and moves the gaming community into another core group (people with musical training), that seems counter intuitive to the wii is for every one argument. it would be like making a game called wii print, and it be about layout and page design with a mixture of indesign/illustrator/motion, and livetype and reviewers pan it, but you say its good despite panning it, and the core group does not like it because its too hard.
(personally id like a livetype game)
games are supposed to be fun, and if it fails that first step regardless of if its too hard or broke, or to easy and if it fails that it can be claimed not to be a good game, and from what it sounds like form reviews, it is not a fun game unless you are part of a subgroup of gamers
edit, compare this to mario paint, do you remember how fun that was on the snes and what you could do musically on there without real instruments.
come play minecraft @ mcg.hansrotech.com
minecraft name: hansrotec
XBL name: Goddog
