Tell me, is it ok for someone to hog up a thread about Forza with praise about Gran Turismo? Just tell me if that's ok, if it is, argument over.
It's not that you're not praising the game, you don't have to. I just don't see why other games have to be brought up, or posts like "I fell asleep during the game" are now considered ok. I wouldn't personally care if those same people posted such lines in threads of games that they favor. I'm saying, be fair about it.
If the praise of the other game is done to contrast it with the title of the thread, then the praise makes sense. And that is what I am doing with Uncharted. I am not about to end up saying that MGS4 suck (I don't believe it does), just that I believe that Uncharted series is better for a movie experience in a game, and I explained why. MGS4 is one of the best games of this generation, and one of the finest examples of interactive fiction we have run into, despite its issues I have discussed. I don't believe it is the "BEST GAME EVER" though, and certainl doesn't dwarf the best of movie making.