Uncharted 2 a billion times better than modern gayfare 2.

mod edit: This has been moderated.  So quit reporting it or I'll bop you one.

Well i have played both (havn't finished MW2 yet though but probably today) and in all honesty it has to go to uncharted 2 in my books. I think it will be split though and both games will get there fair share of game of the year awards. Video games need an oscars, where one organization is recognised as THE authority and hands out GOTY among other awards, so that it actually means something.

Easily Uncharted 2.

did you play it? and i mean without jugding it before playing?

Demon Soul ?

never played any of those 3 games but it is the one I would pick up

Uncharted 2 however MW2 is a close second.

uncharted 2 and if MW2 wins this it's gonna be base purely in its hype and popularity kinda like gta4 last year (not sayin MW2 is crap)

Uncharted 2's Single player is full of pure epicness where as MW2 is the equivalent to taking a shit but a lot less interesting. As for the muliplayer i havent played MW2 MP yet but since Uncharted 2 was able to give me a good SP and MP no amount of shit they put into MW2's MP will make up for it. Uncharted 2 GOTY!!!!!

GTA4 WASN'T F#UCKING CRAP

I have played them both, from a technical standpoint.. UNCHARTED 2
From a sales standpoint... MODERN WARFARE 2

My opinion.... after playing uncharted 2, modern warfare just didnt do it for me lol

Then again after playing uncharted 2 I doubt any game will excite me anymore