I'm going to say the technically better experience is MGS4 (Uncharted had some texture pop-in and screen tearing half way through, especially in the jet ski section, in my experiences of 2 run throughs). I experienced no graphical issues with MGS4 (which is surprising given how good the game looks most of the time).

But to be honest, after playing Uncharted a second time, the locations (the level of detail when you're scaling the side of anything i.e cliffs) and character models make it much more impressive for me when it's engine is on stride (which is 98% of the time, minus the jet ski segment and the plot twist, which brought with it some pretty uninspiring indoor visuals).

So I'm going to say Uncharted (U2: AT looks amazing from what I've seen so far).

Damnit such a hard choice....

I think I will go with Uncharted by a small margin.

Uncharted wins this one.

Uncharted - Animations/physics, textures, scale, depth of field...
MGS4 - Character models, particle effects...


^Agree with this

I love both games but technically is uncharted a class of its own.

Uncharted looks better.

MGS4

I say MGS4, some times i think its even better than Killzone 2

Ahh crap two PS3 exclusive this ones going to be hard

Ummm, I can't decide and I haven't played Uncharted in a long while so I'm going to play it again, I'll give my answer tomorrow.

While Uncharted looks better in those photos, and I love the colour, I would have to give this to MGS4. Though I was far more impressed with Uncharted technically- no install and ran great- this is graphics only, so:

MGS4.

Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots

Easy.