By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Movies & TV - The Marvelous Marvel Rewatch (Now Playing: Avengers: Infinity War)

 

Best MCU sub-series?

Iron Man 1 3.03%
 
Thor 1 3.03%
 
Captain America 12 36.36%
 
The Avengers 9 27.27%
 
Guardians of the Galaxy 10 30.30%
 
Total:33
Volterra_90 said:
The Fury said:

They showed a lot but by Avengers it was seemingly removed from his character. I don't blame them, it's a hard thing to try and portray. Part of what makes Marvel characters so good is their flaws, they are relatable, Tony has a big one that was part of his character for many years. I'm sad they weren't able to show it fully, you'd think a guy who was getting drunk because he was dying from a bit of poisoning would turn more to alcohol after the Avengers thing but at the same time, understand how it's not the easiest to do in a film about a 'superhero'.

Got it! I think they tried to do it in a different way in Iron Man 3 showing a post traumatic syndrome. I've really enjoyed that approach because Tony Stark alcohol abuse was portrayed in 2 already, and we could see a different part of his character. In the end of Iron Man 3 he seemed more reassured about himself and I think it's fitting than in the next movies he seemed a more stable guy.

He may not be drinking as much, but stable? I think you need thid rewatch to refresh your mind



Around the Network
mZuzek said:
mZuzek said:

Gonna probably try to watch Iron Man tonight or tomorrow night. It was hard with all the crap that happened (my PC is still very much the same, I'm gonna see what I can do about it soon but for the time being I'm using my brother's Mac *pukes* as he's traveling right now), and also with how it was still very much GotG season here, but now I think that's mostly done. I'm actually writing some stuff on GotG Vol. 2 now so I can post it here when the time comes (a post planned 4 months in advance, that must be some record!), but once I'm done with that I'll begin to move on I think.

Okay, I am done here now and holy crap I must say I'm pretty impressed with myself. I will save this somewhere for the next 4 months, sure, but really if with this text I can't make people understand my point of view then I truly don't know what will. Obviously I hope people won't just understand, but also even change their opinion, but only time will tell, really.

I'm gonna have some lunch now and relax. I've probably been thinking about these things somewhat nonstop for the last 12 hours (including sleep), so it was great to write it down even if I'm not sharing it for a good while, and now that it's done I can definitely move on... have some lunch, play some Okami this afternoon or whatever - and yeah, hopefully watch Iron Man tonight. I don't think I'll give as high a score as most have, but that isn't to say I don't enjoy it!

Your obsession with these movies might just be a tad unhealthy



Watched The Incredible Hulk movie last night, because I doubt I'll be able to see it this weekend.  (Spoilers below.  Don't read if you've never seen the movie.)

Pluses:
Ed Norton, Liv Tyler, and William Hurt all did a great job acting.  I was into all 3 characters.  William Hurt, in particular, just totally embodies General Ross.  I was impressed since that is not the type of role I normally see him do.

My favorite scene in the movie is the beginning where there is a chase in the streets and rooftops of Brazil.  Very cool and exciting scene.

Loved that there was all of this build up about "Mr. Blue" and in the end you gradually find out its a scientist who is not quite right in the head.  That is an interesting twist.

Liked that he wore a heart monitor for the film.  It was a great way to communicate the tension of him potentially turning into the Hulk.



Minuses:
I feel they made several choices in this movie because it was made so recently after the Eric Bana film, and the movie is worse for it.  A big one is that they did a quick montage at the beginning explaining the Hulk's origin.  I think in 2008, I preferred this because, I didn't want to see another Hulk origin.  Now in 2018 I see that the film would have been a lot better with a good fleshed out origin like Iron Man or Captain America.  Because this movie is connected to the MCU, this is the Hulk movie that people are going to watch more from here til the end of time.

The Incredible Hulk movie seems very disconnected to the MCU.  Ed Norton and Mark Ruffalo do Bruce Banner so differently that they feel like two different characters.  We never see Betty Ross, or the Leader or Abomination ever again.  The only character we see again is General Ross and that is not until Civil War 8 years later.  It is very easy to miss this character appeared before unless you are really paying attention.  This movie is the red headed step child of the MCU.

The end battle with Abomination was kind of meh.

Confused about SHIELD's role in this movie.  Seems like SHIELD is working for General Ross.  Then at the end Tony Stark comes in and says they are putting together a super team.  What?  Didn't SHIELD approach Tony Stark?

Why did Betty Ross stop the Hulk from killing Abomination?  It's basically just as dangerous as Godzilla.  How are they going to contain it?  Since I just saw Iron Man, I find it ironic that Stain had to die, but Abomination gets to live.  WTF?



This movie had a lot of parts I liked, but it had several other things pulling it down.

5/10

Last edited by The_Liquid_Laser - on 03 January 2018

The_Liquid_Laser said:

Watched The Incredible Hulk movie last night, because I doubt I'll be able to see it this weekend.  (Spoilers below.  Don't read if you've never seen the movie.)

Pluses:
Ed Norton, Liv Tyler, and William Hurt all did a great job acting.  I was into all 3 characters.  William Hurt, in particular, just totally embodies General Ross.  I was impressed since that is not the type of role I normally see him do.

My favorite scene in the movie is the beginning where there is a chase in the streets and rooftops of Brazil.  Very cool and exciting scene.

Loved that there was all of this build up about "Mr. Blue" and in the end you gradually find out its a scientist who is not quite right in the head.  That is an interesting twist.

Liked that he wore a heart monitor for the film.  It was a great way to communicate the tension of him potentially turning into the Hulk.



Minuses:
I feel they made several choices in this movie because it was made so recently after the Eric Bana film, and the movie is worse for it.  A big one is that they did a quick montage at the beginning explaining the Hulk's origin.  I think in 2008, I preferred this because, I didn't want to see another Hulk origin.  Now in 2018 I see that the film would have been a lot better with a good fleshed out origin like Iron Man or Captain America.  Because this movie is connected to the MCU, this is the Hulk movie that people are going to watch more from here til the end of time.

The Incredible Hulk movie seems very disconnected to the MCU.  Ed Norton and Mark Ruffalo do Bruce Banner so differently that they feel like two different characters.  We never see Betty Ross, or the Leader or Abomination ever again.  The only character we see again is General Ross and that is not until Civil War 8 years later.  It is very easy to miss this character appeared before unless you are really paying attention.  This movie is the red headed step child of the MCU.

The end battle with Abomination was kind of meh.

Confused about SHIELD's role in this movie.  Seems like SHIELD is working for General Ross.  Then at the end Tony Stark comes in and says they are putting together a super team.  What?  Didn't SHIELD approach Tony Stark?

Why did Betty Ross stop the Hulk from killing Abomination?  It's basically just as dangerous as Godzilla.  How are they going to contain it?  Since I just saw Iron Man, I find it ironic that Stain had to die, but Abomination gets to live.  WTF?



This movie had a lot of parts I liked, but it had several other things pulling it down.

5/10

I’m looking forward to this rewatch. I liked Incredible Hulk when it came out and it has held up on subsequent viewings. I get the origin part. Not really thinking in terms of longevity there. Although a little confused that one of your minuses in the failure of the MCU to follow up on this film. That’s not really THIS film’s fault. I do know there are certain rights issues that has pushed a stand-alone Hulk film to the back burner. I also did not like how Betty just disappeared. I really liked the Betty/Banner romance. Starting with Thor the romance formula quickly becomes “here are my abs and now we’re in love”. The romance in Hulk felt real. I especially detested that Betty was jettisoned for that ill conceived Widow/Hulk romance. But we can discuss that when we get to Ultron.

As for who General Ross was working for, I don’t believe it was SHIELD. I think it was just a group within the US military. Which makes sense as the military developed the super soldier formula before SHIELD even existed. I would also recommend the Marvel One Shot: The Consultant which actually puts the Hulk tag in a new light and gives it a twist



Without having done the rewatch yet, all I'll say about the incredible Hulk, is that I actually liked the fact that they basically skipped the origin the story. In my opinion, everything that comes before Bruce Banner becoming the Hulk, and that actual process, isn't really important at all. He's your standard super smart scientist character, working on some project or other to serve a greater good, he's a nice, timid guy, blablabla, something goes wrong, he becomes the Hulk. None of that is important to what defines him as a character, which - to me at least - is the duality and the fear that comes with his being the Hulk. The "other guy," and the genuine worry he has for something triggering him into this uncontrollable wrecking ball of destruction is the important thing you have to establish when you're trying to let people in on who this guy is, and I feel the Incredible Hulk did this very well. At least I did when I last saw it.



Around the Network

Great Idea - tagging I'm in. I'll try to catch up my late scores.



Doc755 said:
The_Liquid_Laser said:

Watched The Incredible Hulk movie last night, because I doubt I'll be able to see it this weekend.  (Spoilers below.  Don't read if you've never seen the movie.)

Pluses:
Ed Norton, Liv Tyler, and William Hurt all did a great job acting.  I was into all 3 characters.  William Hurt, in particular, just totally embodies General Ross.  I was impressed since that is not the type of role I normally see him do.

My favorite scene in the movie is the beginning where there is a chase in the streets and rooftops of Brazil.  Very cool and exciting scene.

Loved that there was all of this build up about "Mr. Blue" and in the end you gradually find out its a scientist who is not quite right in the head.  That is an interesting twist.

Liked that he wore a heart monitor for the film.  It was a great way to communicate the tension of him potentially turning into the Hulk.



Minuses:
I feel they made several choices in this movie because it was made so recently after the Eric Bana film, and the movie is worse for it.  A big one is that they did a quick montage at the beginning explaining the Hulk's origin.  I think in 2008, I preferred this because, I didn't want to see another Hulk origin.  Now in 2018 I see that the film would have been a lot better with a good fleshed out origin like Iron Man or Captain America.  Because this movie is connected to the MCU, this is the Hulk movie that people are going to watch more from here til the end of time.

The Incredible Hulk movie seems very disconnected to the MCU.  Ed Norton and Mark Ruffalo do Bruce Banner so differently that they feel like two different characters.  We never see Betty Ross, or the Leader or Abomination ever again.  The only character we see again is General Ross and that is not until Civil War 8 years later.  It is very easy to miss this character appeared before unless you are really paying attention.  This movie is the red headed step child of the MCU.

The end battle with Abomination was kind of meh.

Confused about SHIELD's role in this movie.  Seems like SHIELD is working for General Ross.  Then at the end Tony Stark comes in and says they are putting together a super team.  What?  Didn't SHIELD approach Tony Stark?

Why did Betty Ross stop the Hulk from killing Abomination?  It's basically just as dangerous as Godzilla.  How are they going to contain it?  Since I just saw Iron Man, I find it ironic that Stain had to die, but Abomination gets to live.  WTF?



This movie had a lot of parts I liked, but it had several other things pulling it down.

5/10

I’m looking forward to this rewatch. I liked Incredible Hulk when it came out and it has held up on subsequent viewings. I get the origin part. Not really thinking in terms of longevity there. Although a little confused that one of your minuses in the failure of the MCU to follow up on this film. That’s not really THIS film’s fault. I do know there are certain rights issues that has pushed a stand-alone Hulk film to the back burner. I also did not like how Betty just disappeared. I really liked the Betty/Banner romance. Starting with Thor the romance formula quickly becomes “here are my abs and now we’re in love”. The romance in Hulk felt real. I especially detested that Betty was jettisoned for that ill conceived Widow/Hulk romance. But we can discuss that when we get to Ultron.

As for who General Ross was working for, I don’t believe it was SHIELD. I think it was just a group within the US military. Which makes sense as the military developed the super soldier formula before SHIELD even existed. I would also recommend the Marvel One Shot: The Consultant which actually puts the Hulk tag in a new light and gives it a twist

(referring to the bold)  I agree that this is really not this film's fault.  I am criticizing the MCU continuity for Hulk as a whole, but this seems to be the best place to talk about it.  If it's anyone's fault is Kevin Feige's, since he handles continuity between the films.  He really throws this film under the bus.  Maybe Universal hasn't given him a choice?  I don't know.

Now that I've rewatched this movie, I find that, like you, I like the Betty/Banner romance.  However, it doesn't exist at all (even as a memory) in the other MCU films.  Banner has reservations about hooking up with Widow but they never suggest it's because of Betty.  And the Banner/Widow relationship doesn't only exist in Avengers 2, because they make reference to it in both Civil War and Thor: Ragnarok.  The MCU as a whole treats Betty like she never existed, and kind of treats this whole film like it never existed.

Also SHIELD is definitely in this movie, even though Nick Fury and Coulson are not.  I'll let you watch it and see if you can make sense of SHIELD's role.  I couldn't.

Last edited by The_Liquid_Laser - on 04 January 2018

ClassicGamingWizzz said:

I dont get the hate for man of steel. its one of the best comic movies IMO, it is the one that have the best fight scenes , 8 / 10

 

BvsS was ok , 6/10

 

Suicide squad was the worst movie i saw i think, its a turd with nothing good, that shit won a oscar lmao...

Wonder woman was good until the moustache guy in the end, the most stupid looking villain of all time.

Justice league is probably a turd, joss weadon destroyed the movie from what i see people talk.

 

I want to participate in this. There some martvels movies i only saw one time. 

 

I love Man of Steel.

Strangely, I was able to enjoy most of the DC movies you listed, even Suicide Squad. Wonder Woman is my least favorite. 



I am the black sheep     "of course I'm crazy, but that doesn't mean I'm wrong."-Robert Anton Wilson

The_Liquid_Laser said:
Doc755 said:

I’m looking forward to this rewatch. I liked Incredible Hulk when it came out and it has held up on subsequent viewings. I get the origin part. Not really thinking in terms of longevity there. Although a little confused that one of your minuses in the failure of the MCU to follow up on this film. That’s not really THIS film’s fault. I do know there are certain rights issues that has pushed a stand-alone Hulk film to the back burner. I also did not like how Betty just disappeared. I really liked the Betty/Banner romance. Starting with Thor the romance formula quickly becomes “here are my abs and now we’re in love”. The romance in Hulk felt real. I especially detested that Betty was jettisoned for that ill conceived Widow/Hulk romance. But we can discuss that when we get to Ultron.

As for who General Ross was working for, I don’t believe it was SHIELD. I think it was just a group within the US military. Which makes sense as the military developed the super soldier formula before SHIELD even existed. I would also recommend the Marvel One Shot: The Consultant which actually puts the Hulk tag in a new light and gives it a twist

(referring to the bold)  I agree that this is really not this film's fault.  I am criticizing the MCU continuity for Hulk as a whole, but this seems to be the best place to talk about it.  If it's anyone's fault is Kevin Feige's, since he handles continuity between the films.  He really throws this film under the bus.  Maybe Universal hasn't given him a choice?  I don't know.

Now that I've rewatched this movie, I find that, like you, I like the Betty/Banner romance.  However, it doesn't exist at all (even as a memory) in the other MCU films.  Banner has reservations about hooking up with Widow but they never suggest it's because of Betty.  And the Banner/Widow relationship doesn't only exist in Avengers 2, because they make reference to it in both Civil War and Thor: Ragnarok.  The MCU as a whole treats Betty like she never existed, and kind of treats this whole film like it never existed.

Also SHIELD is definitely in this movie, even though Nick Fury and Coulson are not.  I'll let you watch it and see if you can make sense of SHIELD's role.  I couldn't.

Will do. I’ll probably watch it on Saturday and we can discuss further!

As for the way the Hulk sub series has been treated, you’re correct, this is a perfect time to discuss but I thought you were marking this film down for that inconsistency which wouldn’t really be fair. That’s all I was saying

Last edited by Doc755 - on 04 January 2018

mZuzek said:
mZuzek said:

I had a 7 in mind before watching it, after watching it I'm leaning more towards an 8 but the film's self-sabotage at the end makes me question that. So, I'm not gonna give it a score for now (lame I know ), gotta think about it more.

Ok, I think I'm gonna play the asshole card and be that dude who always rounds scores down. Really I would ideally have a 7.5 here, but since I don't get that luxury I'm gonna go with a 7 - that's final.

Recorded, thanks!