By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming Discussion - Bold Prediction: Uncharted 4 won't be as good as Rise of the Tomb Raider (Metacritic)

ClassicGamingWizzz said:
Technical aspects - uncharted
Artstyle/howgood looking - uncharted
Story- hand down uncharted
Characters - LOL its uncharted
Gameplay - some people prefer uncharted some prefer tomb raider
Multiplayer - no doubt it will be uncharted

Well the last one is totally obvious since Rise of the Tomb Raider has no multiplayer online or offline.



Around the Network

Uncharted will definitely hit 90 I think. The preview looked brilliant. It looked a lot like Uncharted 2 actually.



Chris Hu said:
ClassicGamingWizzz said:
Technical aspects - uncharted
Artstyle/howgood looking - uncharted
Story- hand down uncharted
Characters - LOL its uncharted
Gameplay - some people prefer uncharted some prefer tomb raider
Multiplayer - no doubt it will be uncharted

Well the last one is totally obvious since Rise of the Tomb Raider has no multiplayer online or offline.


They tried to rip that too, but it was high time they started doing their own thing. Hopefully the second game is a little more Tomb Raider-ish than Uncharted, but from what I am hearing its even more Uncharted than Uncharted. LOL



the_dark_lewd said:
Uncharted will definitely hit 90 I think. The preview looked brilliant. It looked a lot like Uncharted 2 actually.


If they want to send off Uncharted with a bang they will have to almost equal Uncharted 2's quality with the critical reception of the Last of Us. A list of things only Naughty Dog is capable of. Hopefully they follow through because after Uncharted they probably have one or two more games left in them for this gen. 



I could see it, quite honestly. I suppose time will tell, but critics have been getting increasingly harsh on games that don't significantly innovate in some way (with the possible exception of Smash Bros), and UC4 looks to be very much a prettier version of what we've seen before.

I personally wouldn't bet on it, but I wouldn't be surprised either.



Around the Network
MTZehvor said:
I could see it, quite honestly. I suppose time will tell, but critics have been getting increasingly harsh on games that don't significantly innovate in some way (with the possible exception of Smash Bros), and UC4 looks to be very much a prettier version of what we've seen before.

I personally wouldn't bet on it, but I wouldn't be surprised either.


This is a first because we've never seen ND work on a Uncharted with this much power as they've always wanted to (as in from linear and restrained to setpieces, rather than a playground which they had been gunning for since the PS3 era). The adventure will be much larger and as will be the gaming world. We will see how it all goes. 



Tomb Raider has always been a standard for uncharted to attempt to reach...



In terms of gameplay and the amount of extra content, tomb raider has the edge; but story/characters, technical innovation, Uncharted scores that big time. Its the benchmark of PS4 games.



S.T.A.G.E. said:
MTZehvor said:
I could see it, quite honestly. I suppose time will tell, but critics have been getting increasingly harsh on games that don't significantly innovate in some way (with the possible exception of Smash Bros), and UC4 looks to be very much a prettier version of what we've seen before.

I personally wouldn't bet on it, but I wouldn't be surprised either.


This is a first because we've never seen ND work on a Uncharted with this much power as they've always wanted to. The adventure will be much larger and as will be the gaming world. We will see how it all goes.

The same can be said for any first iteration of a series on new hardware, and, far more often than not, it doesn't lead to a drastically bigger game world or adventure. Those usually come later in a console's lifetime, when the developers have a better grasp of what the hardware is capable of.



busbfran said:
Tomb Raider has always been a standard for uncharted to attempt to reach...


Uncharted created its own standard. Ever seen Star Wars 1313 or Wanted? Both games copied Uncharted and Uncharted learned from a multitude of other games just like Gears of War.