By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Website Topics - Would you censor fictional sexual content that depict minors?

 

Would you?

Yes, I'd eliminate or bl... 50 28.57%
 
Yes, I'd edit it to make... 9 5.14%
 
No, I'd leave it be. 71 40.57%
 
Depends on the case, depends on the context. 31 17.71%
 
Show me the answers / I d... 14 8.00%
 
Total:175
LurkerJ said:
archer9234 said:

It is 13.

It's not breaking the law per se. But it will lead to an inevitable bad publicity and unnecessary headache. I am just tired of the "18+", it's an arbitary number and people need to stop making a big deal out of it.

Then you deal with it during creation phase of the game. Not here. Where it's out in the open. XCX goal was to sell WORLD WIDE. respect all areas the worlds rules. And decide on were you stand for the games released content. Because this type of censorship just ends up making the company look like asses.



Around the Network
RenCutypoison said:
Wright said:

Fictional sexual content that depict minors?

 

That's illegal in most first world countries.


Huh, I didn't know that.



artistic expression should imo not be limited if it's _purely fictional_ - if art does depict real people there should ofcourse still be a wealth of creative freedom for showing people of public interest (politicians, celebrities, ..), but also certain limitations for showing people under special protection of the law (minors,..)



Minors and sex are a no go and while I accept what japanese people do with their work of fiction I wouldn't expose people from the west to it (If I worked at Nintendo).






"I've Underestimated the Horse Power from Mario Kart 8, I'll Never Doubt the WiiU's Engine Again"

The issue with sexual content and innuendo and fictional characters is age is what ever the creator says.

Could have a fully developed physically character and say they are 7, or have a child like character and say they are 700. This has happened in the past where character are aged up for western games or ages are removed completely.

I am not in favor of censorship. I agree with rating systems and restrict access real life minors have to certain content though.



Around the Network

Yes, gamers got a bad rep as it is, we don't need to be called pedos too. gg



Bet reminder: I bet with Tboned51 that Splatoon won't reach the 1 million shipped mark by the end of 2015. I win if he loses and I lose if I lost.

First, these are drawings, not actual people. There is no victim and any "age" is assigned, not inherent.

A drawing of a girl with small breasts and minimal curves can be "12" or she can be "18" depending on a whim. The inverse is also true. What we're talking about is pure fiction.

Now, that being said, there are always people looking to attack over any perceived impropriety. Because of that, I don't blame Nintendo. They have to protect themselves first and foremost.

The best way around this, usually, is to simply change the age. That doesn't always work, of course, and depends on the story itself, which should take priority. If you need the girl to be 13 in the story then she should stay 13. If not, change her age and leave the mature content in. I can't speak for this game, however, as I know nothing about it.



http://www.mmo-champion.com/threads/1887863-Japan-urged-to-ban-manga-child-abuse-images

Similar thread. What is considered child abuse in most places is not in Japan. Japan is a more mature country though, in that they can easily deal with sensitive material. So I think it is wrong to block their ideas.

I think western countries are too hung up on random things, and middle eastern countries and China have it worse.

In some ways I think Japan is more advanced then western countries, especially for societal issues.



pokoko said:
First, these are drawings, not actual people. There is no victim and any "age" is assigned, not inherent.

A drawing of a girl with small breasts and minimal curves can be "12" or she can be "18" depending on a whim. The inverse is also true. What we're talking about is pure fiction.

Now, that being said, there are always people looking to attack over any perceived impropriety. Because of that, I don't blame Nintendo. They have to protect themselves first and foremost.

The best way around this, usually, is to simply change the age. That doesn't always work, of course, and depends on the story itself, which should take priority. If you need the girl to be 13 in the story then she should stay 13. If not, change her age and leave the mature content in. I can't speak for this game, however, as I know nothing about it.

For all you know a pedo could use it as inspiration to act it out. I am willing to bet it has happened. They should not under ANY circumstances be placed in the sexual context



I really don't care, so it doesn't impact me in the slightest. I never use those outfits.