Soul caliber! Before that I was good at games but didn't consider myself elite at any particular one.

SMB3 was the first game that I beat before any of my friends / cousins, and I quickly mastered most of the levels (thanks to the official strategy guide lol). Beyond that Contra was another game I owned back in the day.

Vectorman 2 for the genesis. If not that than Sonic 3. Lost track of how many time I would play through those two games.

Hm, Halo 3.

PvP in Runescape after I got my range skillcape.

Crash Team Racing

Tekken 3. It's also the last fighting game I really got into. I could O and X all day with Eddie and beat anyone. Also Paul's fire punch would wreck. Though True Ogre's flames would frustrate people as well. I could also run through Spyro 2 pretty fast back in the PS1 days and still had it on PS3 years later.

I would say Crash Team Racing when I was a kid.

age of empires

considered myself an expert at.... Enduro on the atari 2600, but then again I was also 4 so wasn't really aware of the global lvl of play by other Enduro players!

(or how to not shit myself)