Sonic CD got 2 votes and was ranked 427th overall, but yeah, it's a great game for sure. *salutes*

Thanks. ^_^

Just like old times (The 2010 results thread was my most viewed story, of course it only had to compete with the VGChartz Most Wanted feature and some random comics but... ).

But yeah, whether it's with gamrReview or here on VGChartz, I'd certainly be happy to see it spread its wings a bit. It's been a while since we've had any community participation based content (as the GOTY voting went on to gamrReview and Most Wanted stopped being an editorial when gamrFeed was replaced). I'm all for it, but if you want someone to do the formatting, that would be just fine. I don't want to work on any more game data for a very long while.

Damn, i wasted half an hour of study time reading this

Time well spent

Nice thread.
OOT #1 Rightfully so.

It actually a pretty solid list. And I have played and enjoyed many of them.

With Mario Galaxy at 3 AND 5 i can't take this list seriously. Yes they are great games but letting both games fill up the top 5 is way to much in my opinion. But it's just another list. Not alot of PC games btw.

First, great job on all the work here.

On the list while I have many disagreements, nature of these things. The big shocker to me is how Half-Life (1998-PC) did not even crack the list. I remember that game being hailed with so many games of the year and even game of the decade awards back then. Maybe people have forgotten about it, which is kind of sad even though I am not crazy about FPSs.

That's the only thing that jumped out at you in the top 20?

The key i've noticed is that different Nintendo fans tend to have different preference orders for Galaxy and Galaxy 2, often one or the other is in their top 10 but not both (with me, Galaxy 1 was top 10, Galaxy 2 fell somewhere in the middle of my 50), the key is that they made enough lists and often made it into the top 10 enough that they made it both, cumulatively, into the top 5 (along with Mario 64, my number 3)

Honestly there are more PC and Xbox games than you'd think there'd be, given the size of either fanbase on this site.