my list        1 Ni no kuni ( a ff xii and dq viii mix)

                    2 FF XIII and XIII-2 (great story and characters)

                    3 White Knight Chronicles 1 and 2 (fuck critics this game rocks)

                    4 Eternal Sonata (a fairytale comes to life)

                    5 Valkyria Chronicles (gameplay rocks)

                    6 Disgaea 4( more fun you won 't find nowhere)

                   7 Star Ocean 4(nice worlds and gameplay)

                   8 Tales of graces F(combat and colorful world)

                   9 3d dot game heroes( a hymn to past)

                   10 Atelier Totori( alchemy never was more fun than this)

yours ????????

..should've waited until Xillia was out

yes this list will change with xillia that for sure(top 5)

1.) Dark Soul's
2.) Demon's Soul's
3.) The Last Remnant
4.) Valkyria Chronicles
5.) Arc Rise Fantasia
6.) Final Fantasy XIII-2
7.) Lost Odyssey
8.) Final Fantasy XIII
9.) Nier
10.) Star Ocean: The Last Hope

Currently playing: Ni No Kuni and I wouldn't place it on the top 10. Haven't touched Graces F yet either.

1. Final Fantasy XIII
2. Ni No Kuni
3. Final Fantasy XIII-2
4. Nier (JRPG?)
5. Eternal Sonata

Well I'd put Xenoblade in third place if we include Wii.

1. Tales of Vesperia
2. Star Ocean The Last Hope
3. Final Fantasy XIII
4. Tales of Graces f
5. Final Fantasy XIII-2
6. Lost Odyssey

i think WKC is quite underrated and i don 't know why

Haven't played any JRPG's on the PS3 yet except for the demo for the Ni No Kuni demo. Here is a ranking of the JRPG's I have played and beaten that where released this generation:
1. Lost Odyssey
2. Infinite Undiscovery
3. Eternal Sonata
4. Final Fantasy IV (DS)
5. Final Fantasy III (DS)
Still have to beat Tales of Vesperia which would probably rank near the top and Blue Dragon which would probably rank near the bottom and FFXIII which would rank somewhere in the middle.  Also have The Last Remnant but I doubt I will ever finish that game.

Tales of Graces!!!!!!!!!

1. Valkyria Chronicles