Insider Reports Suggest That Focus On Eternal Darkness 2 Has Crippled Silicon Knights

Forums - Gaming Discussion - Insider Reports Suggest That Focus On Eternal Darkness 2 Has Crippled Silicon Knights

Tagged games:

Insider Reports Suggest That Focus On Eternal Darkness 2 Has Crippled Silicon Knights

Posted Sat, 27 Oct 2012 | 15:15 BST by Damien McFerran

Eternally in development hell?

Less than five staffers remain

After the critical disaster that was X-Men Destiny, things were looking pretty bleak for developer Silicon Knights. However, a recent report by Kotaku — based on interviews with former staff members — reveals just how bad things have become. The studio is believed to have less than five employees, including company president Denis Dyack himself.

The sources quoted in Kotaku's investigation have stated that during the development of X-Men Destiny for Activision, Dyack had 40 percent of the company's staff (around 45 people at the time) working on a sequel to the 2002 GameCube title Eternal Darkness - a project which would ultimately lead nowhere:

"SK didn't take the development of [X-Men Destiny] seriously the entire time I was there," a source says. "They were working on an Eternal Darkness 2 demo that they could take to publishers. While I was there, they were even siphoning off staff from my [XMD] team to work on it." Sources allege that many of SK's programmers, artists and designers were not contributing to the final quality of XMD at all — at least, not in the first year of the game's development. "I was always complaining to the producers about this, as the numbers never worked out," the same source says. "Denis is not an X-Men fan either, so he didn't care much for the license. To him, it seemed more like a job to get us by, until ED2 could be developed and sold to a publisher — which never happened."

Silicon Knights' fall from grace has been dramatic. Before X-Men Destiny, the studio's most recent release was Xbox 360 exclusive Too Human, which tanked with both critics and consumers following a long development period. A costly lawsuit with Epic Games (which Silicon Knights eventually lost) has also been in the headlines lately.

Interestingly, another source claims that the rot began after Silicon Knights and Nintendo parted ways - an event which occurred following the release of the GameCube port of Metal Gear Solid: The Twin Snakes.

Nintendo's influence — is it alleged — had an effect on the output of the company, forcing Silicon Knights to create better titles that it perhaps would have done on its own. "Nintendo was going to put their name on the game, so it had to be 'Nintendo quality," claims the source. "Once [Nintendo] were out of the picture, SK could do whatever they wanted. Denis believed that SK was finally out from under the oppressive nature of Nintendo as a publisher. Once Denis was given more freedom, things started to fall apart."

How do you feel knowing that Eternal Darkness 2 was actually in development, but is now unlikely to see the light of day? Are you sad to see this once-great studio reduced to just five people, or is Dyack simply getting what he deserves? Let us know in the comments section.




Around the Network

The question is of course how could SK demo ED2 to other publishers when Nintendo owns the IP

Switch friend-code: 6700-1526-7903

PSN: melbye82

I'd say being run by Denis Dyack has crippled Silicon Knights.

Interesting that SK seems to own the Eternal Darkness IP, though. Unless they just intended to slap a different name on it if a publisher other than Nintendo picked it up.

They were mad Nintendo forced them to create quality titles? They wanted games like Too Human and XMD? xmd sucked.

If you make bad titles it will eventually catch up with you. Hopefully they can still pull it off. If Nintendo wants them to then they will. This is probably just a stunt to get more funding.

    The NINTENDO PACT 2015[2016  Vgchartz Wii U Achievement League! - Sign up now!                      My T.E.C.H'aracter

Around the Network

While I was truly hoping Eternal Darkness II would some day become a reality, in the back of my mind I new Silicon Knights was an incompotent studio.

But how is the legal situation? Could Nintendo make a Sequel to ED on their own if they wanted to? I'm still not sure because i thought they had the rights to the IP, but if SK could just start to work on EDII without an order from Nintendo, they must have some rights to ED too right? Anyway, it would be a shame if we couldn't get a second part just because of this...

Does Nintendo still have a stake in Silicon Knights?

this makes the GC and ED even more valuable

I'm guessing SK's hope was that Nintendo would see the demo and take them back, kinda like a girl who's hoping her billionaire ex-boyfriend will take her back, lol.