He did say in his opinion, whats the problem?

Sorry for any offense.  Selnor just seems to overhype every game, and about every month there is a "new console graphics king".  None of it was meant in a mean-spirited way.

But feel free to keep jumping on, you seem to enjoy it.

No, you're right. He does do that a lot. Selnor likes to hype games up, specefically Xbox 360 exclusives. He makes multiple threads about them each time a little bit more information is leaked i.e. Forza Motorsport 3.

His opinions are fine being opinions, but it is a bit ridiculous when he hasn't even played the game all the way through yet, or at all. Basing best graphics, best story, cinema experience and best RPG all off of screenshots, trailers and leaked videos is a bit over the top.

I actually like lots of threads...its good to see someone get hyped for 360 exclusives like the PS3 ones.  I just chuckled when I saw all that for a game not yet released (like you said).

But on topic: it does look awesome!

Selnor is about the ONLY person on this site who rediculously hypes 360 games. Whereas every ps3 exclusive is hyped like crazy by tons of people, so a crazy hype thread for a ps3 exclusive doesn't stick out. You go to the hot topics and see one 360 hype thread, it sticks out like a sore thumb.

Someone simply has to do it and I'm too busy hyping muliplat games

I'm not that pumped for the game at the moment but will probably get it anyway, and I expect that the game will blow me away once I play it - afterall, mass effect is one of my favourite games this gen.

I'm still waiting on more reviews though (GT and IGN in particular).

Between work and school I've been pretty busy this week, but I plan on putting through some sample stories this weekend and see if I'm up to snuff.

Just now beating Mass Effect way better than I expected. Finally, something I can play from bioware. But, I still can't decide if I should get MAG first or ME2. Two of my friends are getting MAG and I liked the beta. Yet, ME is so badass. Yet, playing with friends beats playing alone so i'll probably wait awhile to get ME2.

Another day on VGC, another "new graphics king" announcement from Selnor... :P

Really want this game. Hopefully my laptop is capable of running it.