Battlefield: Bad Company 2 +
RoF -

Autch, by my calculations, ROF is dead now, with -3 HP total. Darth, Seraphic and Boutros won't be happy :P

Aliens VS Predator + (hold on, my next game!)
Brink -

+ Split/Second

- Dead Space 2

Grr!

+ Fallout
- Mafia II

Updating now

+Mafia II
-Fallout

Haha, oh god, the remaining list of games is horrible : D
anyway:
+Assassin's Creed 2 Expansion
-Fallout New Vegas

Last Vote - PaleFolklore

1) Fallout: New Vegas - 13
2) Rage - 15
3) Prince of Persia - 14
4) Brink - 10
5) Battlefield: Bad Company 2 - 17
6) Dead Space 2 - 27
7) Max Payne 3 - 20
8) Red Dead Redemption - 22
9) Split/Second - 17
10) Naughty Bear - 4
11) Mafia II - 10
12) Assassin's Creed 2 Expansion - 10
13) Aliens VS Predator - 9
14) Lost Planet 2 - 19
15) Dead Rising 2 - 9

Eliminated
16) Resonance of Fate
17) Metal Gear Solid: Rising
18) Just Cause 2
19) Medal of Honor
20) Bioshock 2
21) Crysis 2
22) Project Sonic 2D
23) Nier
24) Dante's Inferno
25) Star Wars: The Force Unleashed 2
26) Final Fantasy XIII
27) Quantum Theory
28) Singularity
29) Kane & Lynch 2: Dogs Days
30) Call of Duty 7

+Rage
-Aliens Vs Predator