DEMONS SOULS!!!!

i am a little sceptical about demon souls (and fat princess) . they are very good games but i dont know if i have enough time for them.....i wont play god of war 3 because even though i really liked the 1st one,,the second one was identical in many ways.

Amusing fact: 20 of those games released in 2008 or 2009.

This is what I don't get from sites and magazines...why bother showering games with praises and award them with high scores and editor's choice distinctions, when at the end of the day (literally) they will make a list of what they consider "top games" and completely go against their own word? Time and time again they insult our intelligence and we come back for more?

are bashing PS3's 2007?

Agree with number 1 and 2. Don't like LBP at 3 and GTA at 4. Infamous should be higher. Don't see any game this gen surpassing MGS 4!!

Resistance is on there, wheres Resistance 2 its way better than the first.

The number 1 and 2 are probably right, but LBP, Flower, Infamous, Warhawk, Resistance and the first Uncharted are overrated.

Still haven't played Valkyria or Demon's Souls and SF IV and Super Stardust should be higher. Also Dead Space should be higher.

Awesome list! I'm so glad they included Fallout 3. I'm a little disappointed that MGS4 is number 1 but I can deal with that.