By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Sony Discussion - Heavy Rain Critic Reception

CGI-Quality said:
S.T.A.G.E. said:
solidpumar said:
You forgot the story mate.
Forget graphics, this game purpose is to give a interactive story, like no other media can.

If you watch the videos and think about graphics or button pressing... you watching it wrong. The game is about the interactive story.

Exactly. The only parts with button pressing at battle sequences which are in hit or miss fashion.

You forgot the parts of walking. You have to press a button to walk. Exploration is something that you can do HEAVY RAIN, and I plan to exercise that ability when it finally arrives.

Yes, you walk to other interaction points. Walking is very good exercise my friend. :)



Around the Network

isn't every game all about button presses and fast reflexes? if heavy rain is anything like that, plus the walking and exploration and that thing that the detective uses then i think heavy rain does fall into the "adventure" genre or at least a genre that is more than an interactive drama. =]



End of 2010 Predictions (Original Prediction Made: Jan. 1, 2010---Revised April 1, 2010---Revised Again July 1, 2010---Revised Again on Nov. 1, 2010)

PS3: 46 MIL (April Revision: 44 MIL, July Revision 43 MIL, Nov. Revision 45MIL)

360: 44 MIL (April Revision: 46 MIL, July Revision: 48 MIL, Nov. Revision 49MIL)

WII: 82 MIL (Apr. Revision: 84 MIL, Jul. Revision: 82 MIL, Nov. Revision: 82MIL)

THE MUST BUY LIST of 2010: Gran Turismo 5

THE BOUGHT LIST of 2010: White Knight Chrnociles, Heavy Rain, Final Fantasy 13, God of War 3, Modnation Racers, Sports Champions

It's going to have a 75 - 90 Metacritic score.



Who's the best Pac, Nas, and Big. Just leave it to that.

PLAYSTATION®3 is the future.....NOW.......B_E_L_I_E_V_E

Slaughterhouse Is The Sh*t  .... NOW ........ B_E_L_I_E_V_E

CGI-Quality said:
Dexorosorous said:
isn't every game all about button presses and fast reflexes? if heavy rain is anything like that, plus the walking and exploration and that thing that the detective uses then i think heavy rain does fall into the "adventure" genre or at least a genre that is more than an interactive drama. =]

As far as I can remember: yes.

haha yeah. and ignoring other people and thinking outside the box. i think you can even compare heavy rain to resident evil 2 (where u controlled 2 different characters and some things change based on how you played the game, even if its just 2 different paths) minus the shooting/combat part/menus and adding more options to use the environment, and more ability to change the story based on your actions. obviously, i guess some people don't like their menus or guns taken out. ;-]



End of 2010 Predictions (Original Prediction Made: Jan. 1, 2010---Revised April 1, 2010---Revised Again July 1, 2010---Revised Again on Nov. 1, 2010)

PS3: 46 MIL (April Revision: 44 MIL, July Revision 43 MIL, Nov. Revision 45MIL)

360: 44 MIL (April Revision: 46 MIL, July Revision: 48 MIL, Nov. Revision 49MIL)

WII: 82 MIL (Apr. Revision: 84 MIL, Jul. Revision: 82 MIL, Nov. Revision: 82MIL)

THE MUST BUY LIST of 2010: Gran Turismo 5

THE BOUGHT LIST of 2010: White Knight Chrnociles, Heavy Rain, Final Fantasy 13, God of War 3, Modnation Racers, Sports Champions

CGI-Quality said:
Dexorosorous said:
CGI-Quality said:
Dexorosorous said:
isn't every game all about button presses and fast reflexes? if heavy rain is anything like that, plus the walking and exploration and that thing that the detective uses then i think heavy rain does fall into the "adventure" genre or at least a genre that is more than an interactive drama. =]

As far as I can remember: yes.

haha yeah. and ignoring other people and thinking outside the box. i think you can even compare heavy rain to resident evil 2 (where u controlled 2 different characters and some things change based on how you played the game, even if its just 2 different paths) minus the shooting/combat part/menus and adding more options to use the environment, and more ability to change the story based on your actions. obviously, i guess some people don't like their menus or guns taken out. ;-]

Must be.

Truth be told, I expect a game like HEAVY RAIN to have a larger amount of critics. It just irritates me when people speak about a game and have little knowledge of it as a whole.

that's true. i am mostly really excited about how the 4 characters will be interacting with each other and mindblown on how much possibilities that they can do with the game. (1x2x3x4 permutation...lol) i think there's like 28 different endings already based on the characters alone. obviously i'm hoping that the death of a main character won't be the only game changer, and that means there's a LOT more possibilities which is really interesting on its own.

the game will be great if its anything like a better indigo prophecy. the game is certainly intriguing, and i think its one of those games that people need to open up their minds into and just let it sink in that it is different than most games/movies or whatever you want to classify it. am i sold on it? of course. but time will tell if i end up liking the game, or just be sorely dissapointed. the only problem is some people just hate on some games because its trying to be different and not the norm (it's like picking on a nerd in school.) =P



End of 2010 Predictions (Original Prediction Made: Jan. 1, 2010---Revised April 1, 2010---Revised Again July 1, 2010---Revised Again on Nov. 1, 2010)

PS3: 46 MIL (April Revision: 44 MIL, July Revision 43 MIL, Nov. Revision 45MIL)

360: 44 MIL (April Revision: 46 MIL, July Revision: 48 MIL, Nov. Revision 49MIL)

WII: 82 MIL (Apr. Revision: 84 MIL, Jul. Revision: 82 MIL, Nov. Revision: 82MIL)

THE MUST BUY LIST of 2010: Gran Turismo 5

THE BOUGHT LIST of 2010: White Knight Chrnociles, Heavy Rain, Final Fantasy 13, God of War 3, Modnation Racers, Sports Champions

Around the Network

I just don't see how anything in it is all that different from any other adventure game other than the control scheme. Instead of "X" being punch, it's "R1" when you are in punching range, or whatever button it prompts you to do. I completely understand if people don't LIKE the control scheme, but that's really the only major difference as far as gameplay is concerned. If you classify this as an "interactive movie", then there have been many, many, many before it.

I haven't decided if I'm getting it yet or not...I'm intrigued by many things, but put off by others (the demo where you put on lipstick...that just seems dumb to me, but that's my opinion). We'll see how it all comes together. But I really dont' see how it could be called an interactive movie any more than countless other video games.



Owner of PS4 Pro, Xbox One, Switch, PS Vita, and 3DS

S.T.A.G.E. said:
Akvod said:
S.T.A.G.E. said:
Torillian said:
Akvod's right, the game is most clearly an adventure game from what we've seen regardless of what David Cage says. Developers can be wrong, and unless the full game is far different from what we've seen I would say Heavy Rain fits quite comfortably in the Adventure genre. it's like a point and click mystery game made for consoles and that would definitely be the adventure genre.

 

I like Akvod, but he's still wrong. David Cage spelled it out....he didn't just talk. He explained what makes it different from an adventure game.

Heavy Rain is often referred to as an adventure game. How do you feel about the application of that genre title to the game? In what ways is it appropriate or inappropriate?- Game Informer to David Cage

"Adventure games are a very clearly defined genre based on established mechanics: exploration, inventory management, puzzles and dialogue choices. There is generally a focus on story and characters with a very slow pacing and cut scenes to make the narrative move forward, generally in a quite linear way.

Based on this definition, Heavy Rain is NOT an adventure game. There is no inventory in the game, no object to combine or examine, no puzzle, the game does not rely on everlasting dialogues. The story is told through players' actions and not through cutscenes, and players' actions have significant consequences on the narrative. Last but not least, Heavy Rain offers a diversity of situations and gameplay, as well as some spectacular action sequences."- David Cage

>.< Why can you not fucking listen, stop pointing to David Cage. Like I said over and over, David Cage isn't infallible and isn't the end all be all.

I disagree that inventory is a fundamental part of adventure games. I can imagine an adventure game without an inventory. In fact, like I showed before, Visual Novels, a sub genre of adventure games, doesn't have an inventory (although there are some that do).

To me an adventure game is simply playing an adventure. The exploration doesn't have to encompass a huge world, but could be as simple as a small police department or house. The game has dialogue, and I don't know what an "Ever lasting dialogue" is.

The game has puzzles, just not traditional ones. The puzzle is how to handle a situation, if you personally want to get a certain outcome. The only thing is that the game doesn't give you an goal. But I'm sure that most of us aren't playing to suicide the player, get caught, and just choosing choices randomly. With our internal goals, I think that the game offers a really cool gameplay based on common sense and quick thinking like in Indigo Prophecy.

*sigh*

See, I get what you're saying with visual novels. Your explanation of an adventure game...well...is off. Certain objects are prescribed for you to look at, you press the interactive button and it interacts. Cage said the game gives you choices and once you make the decisions and it affects the story without disrupting characterization. In the battles when you do the hit or miss button match it helps or seals the fate of your person. Theres no real work for you to do in this game. Yes akvod you are right and Cage is wrong. 

 

Right now, Quantic Dream is the only developer making games in this style, focused so intently on story and character. Why do you think more developers haven’t attempted it?

"Our industry is entirely focused since its creation on creating games for kids and teenagers. What this audience wants is simple instant fun with guns, cars and explosions. Some video games managed to make incredible things based on this paradigm and it is today the most secure choice on a financial standpoint for a publisher.

Quantic (and Sony)’s bet on Heavy Rain is to say that there is another emerging market of young adults and adults looking for a different type of interactive experiences based on a different paradigm: they want experiences that are journeys and not series of obstacles, that bear meaning and emotion and not only adrenaline, that explores other themes closer to cinema or literature, but that are fully interactive and visually stunning."

Err... aren't there are a ton of interactive objects? Especially in the father one, but so in both the agent and detective one (and sorta in the makeup one). I haven't seen any other videos for fear of spoilers though.

There is real work to do in the game. The only problem is that there's no objective source of a goal (no goal given to you by the game). But, if our goal is to get out of the house unseen, we interact with objects and think strategicly. If our goal is get killed we do what needs to be done. Etc. So if you want your character to surive, or some outcome to occur in the story you do have to think about it and do stuff (work).

 

No, Quantic Dream isn't the only developer making games in this style, focused so intenly on story and character. I've yet the time to play visual novels from other companies besides Type Moon, but VNs focused nearly all of their energy on story and character.

And I can give a shit less about the industry, what Cage says, and all the other shit you're saying, because they're completely IRRELEVANT.

 

Look, you're complicating the matter so much unnecessarily.

You've yet to answer my two fucking questions. Just two. You don't have to write an essay or whatever. STOP QUOTING CAGE and tell me what YOU think.

1) What are the CRUCIAL, FOUNDATIONAL properties of an adventure game.

2) Does Heavy Rain stand up to the definition of an adventure game.

 

Just make a short list (remember, these are the MUST HAVE stuff, so it should be a small list). Then highlight the ones that Heavy Rain doesn't have.

 

Here's Wikipedia to give you some inspiration:

Text adventure

Text adventures, also known as Interactive Fiction, convey the game's story through passages of text, revealed to the player in response to typed instructions. Early text adventures, such as Adventure and Scott Adams' games, used a simple verb-noun parser to interpret these instructions, allowing the player to interact with objects at a basic level, for example by typing "get key" or "open door". Later text adventures, and modern interactive fiction, can interpret far more complex sentences.

[edit] Graphic adventure

Graphic adventures are adventure games that use graphics to convey the environment to the player. Games under the graphic adventure banner may have a variety of input types, from text parsers to touch screen interfaces.

Point-and-click adventures are a common type of graphic adventure in which the player uses a pointer, typically a mouse, to interact with the environment and solve puzzles. This input method remains popular in the genre, and is well-suited to interaction with the environment, as opposed to direct control schemes which emphasize character control.

[edit] Puzzle adventure

Puzzle adventures are adventure games that put a strong emphasis on puzzle solving, at the expense of elements such as item gathering, item use, character interaction, or plot. Instead, they typically emphasize exploration and deciphering the proper use of complex mechanisms, often resembling Rube Goldberg machines.

The plot of these games can be obscure, and may be conveyed only through interaction with the puzzles. Many puzzle adventures are played from a first person perspective with the player "moving" between still pre-rendered 3D images, sometimes combined with short animations or video. Examples of the genre include Schizm, Atlantis: The Lost Tales, Riddle of the Sphinx, Zack & Wiki: Quest for Barbaros' Treasure, and Myst, which pioneered this game style.

One kind of puzzle adventure is the Escape the room sub-genre, consisting of short games where the sole object is to find a way to escape from a room. These games are typically implemented in a graphic point-and-click style, which (owing to their popularity on the Internet) are often delivered in Adobe Flash format. Examples of the sub-genre include Submachine-series, Mystery of time and space and Crimson room.

[edit] Visual novel

An image of a visual novel: Visual novels are commonly characterized with dialog boxes and sprites denoting the speaker.

A visual novel (ビジュアルノベル bijuaru noberu?) is an adventure game featuring mostly static graphics, usually with anime-style art. As the name might suggest, they resemble mixed-media novels or tableau vivant stage plays. Visual novels are especially prevalent in Japan, where they make up nearly 70% of PC games released.[39] They are rarely produced for video game consoles, but the more popular games are sometimes ported to systems such as the Dreamcast or the PlayStation 2. The market for visual novels outside of Japan, however, is limited.

Visual novels overlap with Japanese adventure games in many ways, including a menu-based interface for all navigation and interaction, reminiscent of ICOM games. Japanese adventure games very seldom feature on-screen avatars or inventory based puzzles in general, and visual novels have an even further diminished emphasis on puzzles, or indeed gameplay. Instead these titles are driven by narrative, focusing almost exclusively on character interaction, in a structure similar to a Choose Your Own Adventure story.

Visual novels frequently feature romantic storylines in which the main character may end up with one of several possible mates. This premise is similar to dating sims, but they are distinct from them in that they lack stats-based sim elements in which the player builds up his character, instead relying on simple choices of dialog, actions, or navigation.

Visual novels have been a staple of PC software sales in Japan and other East Asian countries for over a decade, so much so that popular titles are open ported to consoles, and some even have manga and anime based upon them; such titles include Kanon (1999), Air (2000), Kimi ga Nozomu Eien (2001), Higurashi no Naku Koro ni (2002), Clannad (2004) and Fate/stay night (2004).

Visual novels are sometimes called "dating sims" in the West, because many visual novels track statistics that the player must build in order to advance the plot. This is also because many visual novels permit a variety of endings, allowing more dynamic reactions to the player's actions than a typical linear adventure plot. The cultural differences between Western and Japanese adventure games are closely related to those in role-playing games, such as the storyline being more linear and tightly-scripted in the latter.



CGI-Quality said:
S.T.A.G.E. said:
CGI-Quality said:
S.T.A.G.E. said:
solidpumar said:
You forgot the story mate.
Forget graphics, this game purpose is to give a interactive story, like no other media can.

If you watch the videos and think about graphics or button pressing... you watching it wrong. The game is about the interactive story.

Exactly. The only parts with button pressing at battle sequences which are in hit or miss fashion.

You forgot the parts of walking. You have to press a button to walk. Exploration is something that you can do HEAVY RAIN, and I plan to exercise that ability when it finally arrives.

Yes, you walk to other interaction points. Walking is very good exercise my friend. :)

I don't suggest you play the game. You can't seem to find really anything positive to say about it.

Well finally you get to the heart of the matter. Only few times have I ever given my true feelings on the title. Subjective feelings and not what I am gathering from videos and reading from interviews. Here is how i feel in points.

- I am intrigued by the mystery which surrounds this title. I have an investigative personality and I must know who the Origami Killer is. Despite the fact that it isn't really that engaging, I really like stories. Think of it as a fascination with mystery novels.

- I have come to the conclusion that since this title is not worth 60 dollars ( I'd probably buy it at 40 or 30 dollars)which is why I am renting it. For two weeks, I will see all there is to see about it and gather my trophies. :)

- I like the fact that it is a dark drama, but takes the time unlike most games and more like movies to focus on the stories of the protagonists and where it all intertwines. 

- This game is the filler of the gap between the film industry and the gaming industry plain and simple. 

- I do not feel that this is an adventure game, because you're just pretty much watch a characters life with interaction buttons, but your decisions depending on which button you press could spell out the truth or the end for you.

 



I'm starting to wonder if you talk crap about Heavy Rain at every possibility because you don't like the idea that Heavy Rain may look like a non game but really it has taken the cornerstones of modern wRPGs (one of your favorite genres): an ability to change the story through your actions and a dialogue system and turns it into a full game.

When you look at them, some the defining characteristics that makes something a wRPG are weirdly familiar to what people will be doing in Heavy Rain.



...

If you like an awesome realistical story, if QTE doesn't bother you and if you like very good graphics i don't see a problem. Maybe the gameplay isn't that great, but who cares, fights are filled with QTE and other important things have nothing to to with the gameplay which you need to move your character. And even i don't think the gameplay will be awful, maybe 7/10 but not above. I'm waiting for that game!



Favourite Games:

PS: Final Fantasy IX, Final Fantasy VII. PS2: Resident Evil 4, Shadow Hearts Covenant, Final Fantasy X, Silent Hill 4, Soul Calibur III. PS3: Metal Gear Solid 4, Heavy Rain, Valkyria Chronicles, Uncharted 2, Mototstorm PR, God of War III, Modern Warfare 2. Xbox: Suteki, Fatal Frame II DC, Jade Empire. 360: Dead Rising, Lost Odyssey, Dead or Alive 4.