By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming Discussion - 720p Versus 1080p HDTVs. The Facts

Gearbox said:
Barozi said:
nordlead said:

1) Basically, 720p is probably the best choice for any screen 50 inches and under.
2) Tv is broadcast in 720p.
3) Consoles are 720p.
4) Blu-Ray is 1080p, but the difference is minor.

1) not true. The reality is that the screen size and sitting distance determine the resolution needed for the average consumer. Any knowledgable consumer should figure out the sitting distance and the size of screen they are going to purchase, and then determine if they can notice a difference between 720 & 1080. Most won't, but some might be able to. You can also use a chart like this one to help you determine what will be cost effective.

2) not true. TV is broadcast in 720p and 1080i, with most channels using 1080i in my area (fox is the only 720p). LCD screens have a native resolution, so being forced to scale from 1080i down to 720p can be bad (if you have a cheap TV). If you want to use that argument, then a good consumer would do research first to determine what the resolution will be for their input source.

3) not true. The PS3 can output 1080p. Not very many games support 1080p, but a few do.

4) this really comes down to point 1 and doesn't make any sense in posting it.

the 360 can do 1080p too......

 

OT: I sit in front of my 24" LCD monitor and I try to watch/play everything in 1080p (or 1200p), so yeah the higher the resolution the better.

ur jking right? 360 can do 1080i not 1080p

no it's true.



Around the Network
Gearbox said:
Barozi said:
nordlead said:

1) Basically, 720p is probably the best choice for any screen 50 inches and under.
2) Tv is broadcast in 720p.
3) Consoles are 720p.
4) Blu-Ray is 1080p, but the difference is minor.

1) not true. The reality is that the screen size and sitting distance determine the resolution needed for the average consumer. Any knowledgable consumer should figure out the sitting distance and the size of screen they are going to purchase, and then determine if they can notice a difference between 720 & 1080. Most won't, but some might be able to. You can also use a chart like this one to help you determine what will be cost effective.

2) not true. TV is broadcast in 720p and 1080i, with most channels using 1080i in my area (fox is the only 720p). LCD screens have a native resolution, so being forced to scale from 1080i down to 720p can be bad (if you have a cheap TV). If you want to use that argument, then a good consumer would do research first to determine what the resolution will be for their input source.

3) not true. The PS3 can output 1080p. Not very many games support 1080p, but a few do.

4) this really comes down to point 1 and doesn't make any sense in posting it.

the 360 can do 1080p too......

 

OT: I sit in front of my 24" LCD monitor and I try to watch/play everything in 1080p (or 1200p), so yeah the higher the resolution the better.

ur jking right? 360 can do 1080i not 1080p

The 360 outputs 1080p signals with the right connection and source. How else would HD-DVD 1080p playback work for example.



Fact my PS3 games and BRs look better on my 1080p tv then they did on my 1080i/720p tv.



Yeah, yeah, call this some inaccurate speculation or whatever you want but I'll say it anyway. And that's without any actual experience with HDTVs (though I have a 22" 1680x1050 monitor and probably enough experience discuss this matter anyway).

If you get used to watching HD feed, be it either 720p or 1080p, you WILL see the difference with TVs under 50". It might take a while at first but once you get used to it, it's pretty clear.

EDIT: And of course all this depends on the distance from the TV. Ought to be rather obvious, though I suppose someone will whine about me forgetting it unless I put this remark here.



go to walmart and watch ESPNHD DTV on A Samsung ether 720 and on a sony bravia 1080 and you will see the difference trust me



Around the Network

chingrin -

That may be mostly due to the fact one is a Samsung and one is a Sony. I wonder what the price difference between a Samsung and a Bravia is...

As for me, I really enjoy my Samsung 50" 720p Plasma. I saved a ton (about $500) by purchasing a 720p over a 1080p. For me, it made the most sense since I own a 360, and wanted to get a larger TV, even if I had to sacrifice a small bit of picture quality to get a killer deal.

A lot of the issue also comes down to the TV you buy. Not all TVs are created equal. You need to pay attention to what the picture quality is like, as a Visio is unlikely to look as good as a Sony (of course, a Visio is about half the price).

Also, none of the OP statements really have anything to do with Blu-Ray. You are going to get a huge difference between a upper-converted DVD on a 720p vs. a blu-ray. Just because it *can* do 1080p doesn't mean it doesn't look purdy on a 720p



Back from the dead, I'm afraid.

mrstickball said:

Also, none of the OP statements really have anything to do with Blu-Ray. You are going to get a huge difference between a upper-converted DVD on a 720p vs. a blu-ray. Just because it *can* do 1080p doesn't mean it doesn't look purdy on a 720p

Sorry but it does, Br looked ok in 720p.

But god damn they look fantastic on a huge 1080p plasma.  Planet Earth becomes an experience. 



JamesCizuz said:



 72 Mbps is uncompressed fully audio/video. 

You are miles out here, depending on the spec, i.e. fps, colour bit depth, chroma resolution etc, uncompressed 1080p video (no audio) would require a bit rate of around 100-300 MBps. The max bit rate for Blu-ray video is 40Mbps by the way.



mrstickball said:
chingrin -

That may be mostly due to the fact one is a Samsung and one is a Sony. I wonder what the price difference between a Samsung and a Bravia is...

As for me, I really enjoy my Samsung 50" 720p Plasma. I saved a ton (about $500) by purchasing a 720p over a 1080p. For me, it made the most sense since I own a 360, and wanted to get a larger TV, even if I had to sacrifice a small bit of picture quality to get a killer deal.

A lot of the issue also comes down to the TV you buy. Not all TVs are created equal. You need to pay attention to what the picture quality is like, as a Visio is unlikely to look as good as a Sony (of course, a Visio is about half the price).

Also, none of the OP statements really have anything to do with Blu-Ray. You are going to get a huge difference between a upper-converted DVD on a 720p vs. a blu-ray. Just because it *can* do 1080p doesn't mean it doesn't look purdy on a 720p

Every Sony LCD TVs include a Samsung made LCD panel.............



PS3-Xbox360 gap : 1.5 millions and going up in PS3 favor !

PS3-Wii gap : 20 millions and going down !

umm whoever posted this im gonna ask you something and you dont have to answer if you dont want to

1.do you abuse drugs on a daily basis??

2.is the drug problem the sole cause of the retarded logic?


thanks