..... The lack of Demon's Soul is dissapointing. I'll pass this year.

i think ps3 goty should be uncharted 2:among thieves
my personal fav ps3 games this year is uncharted 2:among thieves and infamous.

This is like selecting the all star team every year for sports. There are gonna be some guys that deserve to make it but don't. Fact is all those games are great but what makes ACII and B:AA make the list and not Infamous or Demon Souls is sales and mainstream appeal. They should have a separate category for best niche games or something. Demon Souls would surely win that category.

I think their list is perfect.

i wish we could email them your idea, but they wont consider it cause they are too popular lol, good idea though...

I was about to write something along those lines, but you summed it up pretty well.

Demon's Souls should win the GOTY but thats just my opinion.

it realize that all of them dont have to be exclusive....but i think that demons souls/infamous deserve a spot, even if they werent exclusive....i mean mabye not infamous, but demon souls for sure....they just happen to be ps3 exclusives, but mabye batman deserves it more than infamous...meh now i cnt decide lol

do you think that demons souls DESERVES GOTY....like was it really IYO the best game of this year

Yes, i personally don't care which game sold more, which is more popular than the other. im sure most people will pick U2 as their GOTY but mine is Demon's Souls.