By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Sales - Which game will sell more. Heavy Rain or Epic Mickey

Heavy Rain

Ok I am going to let you guys on a secret … Mickey and Mario are evil! shh! Don’t tell I told you but
they plan to take over the world!



Around the Network
CGI-Quality said:
Slimebeast said:
CGI-Quality said:
Slimebeast said:
CGI-Quality said:
Slimebeast said:
CGI those are very reasonable arguments about genres of Uncharted and Heavu Rain and in my soul I agree with them, but u realize ur going against the majority consensus rite?

Majority consensus says Uncharted belongs in the action genre, and sub-genre would be action-adventure.
Majority says Heavy rain belongs in the adventure genre, and sub-genre would be adventure-thriller perhaps.

Uncharted 2 is an action-adventure, but I never argued that. The genre is still adventure in Uncharted 2's case though. In fact, the only reason I mentioned Uncharted 2 is because it's adventure game that I thoroughly enjoyed. Other than that, it has no real relevance to this discussion.

Now, most people I talk to about HEAVY RAIN think it's a horror game of some sort (or see it as a serial killer style game) so I'm not aware of this " majority consensus" you speak of in regard to that. Furthermore, I doubt when the average customer looks at the box, they say "wow, this looks like an adventure". Yes, it will have adventurous aspects, I've said this before, but it will not be an adventure game, relative to genre.

As different as Alan Wake and HEAVY RAIN are, they are still in the same genre, and are both sub-genres of that: Psychological Thriller (Horror Genre).

Yeah, Heavy Rain and Alan Wake both belong to the horror genre when it comes to thematic genre classification.

But when it oomes to genre classification from a gameplay mechanics perspectivce they're in different genres - Alan Wake is an action game and Heavy Rain would be what people see as 'adventure'.

And we'll continue to disagree.

I haven't met a person yet, (in prerson that is) that knows what HEAVY RAIN is/about, that considers it an adventure game. Furthermore, people are comparing Alan Wake to another Horror game: SILENT HILL 2. Sure, both games (SH2, AW) have action and guns, so what? Does that make them action-shooters? No.

Bottomline, HEAVY RAIN = Psychological Thriller Alan Wake = Psychological Thriller

Both in the same genre (Horror) with different game play mechanics.

 

Yes we'll continue to disagree but you must agree though that there also exists, at least theoretically, genre classifications based on game play mechanics, yes?

Perhaps. But this whole time, I was speaking about public perspective.

In the public eye, HEAVY RAIN will be seen as a serial killer/thriller experience, not an adventure game. That's all I'm getting at.

I don't follow Heavy Rain extensively. I have watched gameplay videos here and there. I know there are 4 main characters or something like that. I do think it's an adventure game though even if it's a thriller. :x

OT: Epic Mickey. Regardless who is making the game or if this game turns out to be good, it would sell on brand name and marketing alone. There is no way Disney would just release it and not market it heavily.



MikeB predicts that the PS3 will sell about 140 million units by the end of 2016 and triple the amount of 360s in the long run.

CGI-Quality said:
saicho said:
CGI-Quality said:
Slimebeast said:
CGI-Quality said:
Slimebeast said:
CGI-Quality said:
Slimebeast said:
CGI those are very reasonable arguments about genres of Uncharted and Heavu Rain and in my soul I agree with them, but u realize ur going against the majority consensus rite?

Majority consensus says Uncharted belongs in the action genre, and sub-genre would be action-adventure.
Majority says Heavy rain belongs in the adventure genre, and sub-genre would be adventure-thriller perhaps.

Uncharted 2 is an action-adventure, but I never argued that. The genre is still adventure in Uncharted 2's case though. In fact, the only reason I mentioned Uncharted 2 is because it's adventure game that I thoroughly enjoyed. Other than that, it has no real relevance to this discussion.

Now, most people I talk to about HEAVY RAIN think it's a horror game of some sort (or see it as a serial killer style game) so I'm not aware of this " majority consensus" you speak of in regard to that. Furthermore, I doubt when the average customer looks at the box, they say "wow, this looks like an adventure". Yes, it will have adventurous aspects, I've said this before, but it will not be an adventure game, relative to genre.

As different as Alan Wake and HEAVY RAIN are, they are still in the same genre, and are both sub-genres of that: Psychological Thriller (Horror Genre).

Yeah, Heavy Rain and Alan Wake both belong to the horror genre when it comes to thematic genre classification.

But when it oomes to genre classification from a gameplay mechanics perspectivce they're in different genres - Alan Wake is an action game and Heavy Rain would be what people see as 'adventure'.

And we'll continue to disagree.

I haven't met a person yet, (in prerson that is) that knows what HEAVY RAIN is/about, that considers it an adventure game. Furthermore, people are comparing Alan Wake to another Horror game: SILENT HILL 2. Sure, both games (SH2, AW) have action and guns, so what? Does that make them action-shooters? No.

Bottomline, HEAVY RAIN = Psychological Thriller Alan Wake = Psychological Thriller

Both in the same genre (Horror) with different game play mechanics.

 

Yes we'll continue to disagree but you must agree though that there also exists, at least theoretically, genre classifications based on game play mechanics, yes?

Perhaps. But this whole time, I was speaking about public perspective.

In the public eye, HEAVY RAIN will be seen as a serial killer/thriller experience, not an adventure game. That's all I'm getting at.

I don't follow Heavy Rain extensively. I have watched gameplay videos here and there. I know there are 4 main characters or something like that. I do think it's an adventure game though even if it's a thriller. :x

OT: Epic Mickey. Regardless who is making the game or if this game turns out to be good, it would sell on brand name and marketing alone. There is no way Disney would just release it and not market it heavily.

You just make my point though. You aren't who I'm talking about ""

Fine!

but I don't think general public would be able to tell the difference between an adventure game and a thriller. That's challenge the game will face.



MikeB predicts that the PS3 will sell about 140 million units by the end of 2016 and triple the amount of 360s in the long run.

CGI-Quality said:
Slimebeast said:
CGI-Quality said:
Slimebeast said:
CGI-Quality said:
Slimebeast said:
CGI those are very reasonable arguments about genres of Uncharted and Heavu Rain and in my soul I agree with them, but u realize ur going against the majority consensus rite?

Majority consensus says Uncharted belongs in the action genre, and sub-genre would be action-adventure.
Majority says Heavy rain belongs in the adventure genre, and sub-genre would be adventure-thriller perhaps.

Uncharted 2 is an action-adventure, but I never argued that. The genre is still adventure in Uncharted 2's case though. In fact, the only reason I mentioned Uncharted 2 is because it's adventure game that I thoroughly enjoyed. Other than that, it has no real relevance to this discussion.

Now, most people I talk to about HEAVY RAIN think it's a horror game of some sort (or see it as a serial killer style game) so I'm not aware of this " majority consensus" you speak of in regard to that. Furthermore, I doubt when the average customer looks at the box, they say "wow, this looks like an adventure". Yes, it will have adventurous aspects, I've said this before, but it will not be an adventure game, relative to genre.

As different as Alan Wake and HEAVY RAIN are, they are still in the same genre, and are both sub-genres of that: Psychological Thriller (Horror Genre).

Yeah, Heavy Rain and Alan Wake both belong to the horror genre when it comes to thematic genre classification.

But when it oomes to genre classification from a gameplay mechanics perspectivce they're in different genres - Alan Wake is an action game and Heavy Rain would be what people see as 'adventure'.

And we'll continue to disagree.

I haven't met a person yet, (in prerson that is) that knows what HEAVY RAIN is/about, that considers it an adventure game. Furthermore, people are comparing Alan Wake to another Horror game: SILENT HILL 2. Sure, both games (SH2, AW) have action and guns, so what? Does that make them action-shooters? No.

Bottomline, HEAVY RAIN = Psychological Thriller Alan Wake = Psychological Thriller

Both in the same genre (Horror) with different game play mechanics.

 

Yes we'll continue to disagree but you must agree though that there also exists, at least theoretically, genre classifications based on game play mechanics, yes?

Perhaps. But this whole time, I was speaking about public perspective.

In the public eye, HEAVY RAIN will be seen as a serial killer/thriller experience, not an adventure game. That's all I'm getting at.

When someone claim a game is an 'adventure game' they are generally refering to the genre that has been clearly define rather than some ambigious and debatable public perception. The former is a firm concept that has clearly define rule while the later is far more nebulous and can shift depending on person to person.

I can have a good argument that uncharted is a shooter for example, because there's a lot of shooting involve in it and I can make a pormise to you that dragging a few random joe of the street will see at least a good number of them agree with me. Perception is not a classification.

Heavy Rain IS an adventure game, just like Mario is a platformer and Halo is a FPS, these are classification and they should be adhere to because the public perception isn't a measuring stick on how a game should be categorised. To the public, Gears of War and Halo are both 'shooters' but we clearly label them TPS and FPS even if we too call them shooters.

There is no argument here because public perception isn't measuring stick for genre, it's a label to describe the game from a person's perspective and we're simply not speaking on the same wavelength.

However I feel you should concede that it is very valid to call Heavy Rain an adventure game, exactly as how its predecessor was classified.




Epic Mickey...

Anyway doesn't Heavy Rain fall in the same category like Space Ace (1984) and Dragon's Lair (1983) which where totally awesome games...



 

Face the future.. Gamecenter ID: nikkom_nl (oh no he didn't!!) 

Around the Network
CGI-Quality said:

A. HEAVY RAIN doesn't have a predecessor.

B. Even though it may seem like an adventure, that's not the genre.

C. Can we drop this already, it's gotten old at this point and is now only derailing the thread.

A) Farenheit / Indigo Prophecy

B) According to IGN:

Also Known As: Heavy Rain: The Origami Killer [demo title]
Exclusively on: PlayStation 3
Genre: Adventure  <<<<<<<<<<<<take note!
Publisher: Sony Computer Entertainment
Developer: Quantic Dream
OFLC Rating: RP

Just an example but certainly not a voice alone!

C) I'll let it drop now.




Soriku said:
Zucas said:
Well I think most agree that Heavy Rain is a tougher sale but also Heavy Rain has been hyped for a couple of years now. Epic Mickey has had a GI cover and some talk before it about its existence. If that continues, Heavy Rain will easily crush its sales due to lack of hyping and marketing for the other. Of course I would hope Disney would market it as a big game on Wii, but given track record of Wii games before this, I wouldn't be surprised if they didn't.


For now I'm going to go with Heavy Rain, but as for potential, the potential of sales for Epic Mickey exceeds that of Heavy Rain but its just whether or not Disney wants to pursue those. Considering I'm still picking Heavy Rain, shows you how much faith I actually have in them haha.

I don't think you know this but they already stated that Epic Mickey is a big deal for the entire company and such. They're going to market it loads, this isn't a niche game.

Yeah, I don't understand how people miss this (though maybe they haven't looked into things). Disney went out of their way to acquire Junction Point Studios (Warren Spector) in order to make this game, why would they skimp out on advertisement? That would be a huge waste of money. This is one of the few AAA western titles on the Wii, it can't be compared to other games crapped out on the DS / Wii.

Also, it's freaking Mickey Mouse, the company mascot. He may not be as big as Mario, but he fares pretty well when compared to the rest of the games Disney has come out with.

Finally, Warren Spector's involvement really seals the deal. The chances of the game disappointing are slim, as he's got a great track record.

I'll say this right now, I'll be surprised (and disappointed) if the game doesn't nab at least 2 million (I'm expecting a lot more, tbh).



Soriku said:
Zucas said:
Well I think most agree that Heavy Rain is a tougher sale but also Heavy Rain has been hyped for a couple of years now. Epic Mickey has had a GI cover and some talk before it about its existence. If that continues, Heavy Rain will easily crush its sales due to lack of hyping and marketing for the other. Of course I would hope Disney would market it as a big game on Wii, but given track record of Wii games before this, I wouldn't be surprised if they didn't.


For now I'm going to go with Heavy Rain, but as for potential, the potential of sales for Epic Mickey exceeds that of Heavy Rain but its just whether or not Disney wants to pursue those. Considering I'm still picking Heavy Rain, shows you how much faith I actually have in them haha.

 

I don't think you know this but they already stated that Epic Mickey is a big deal for the entire company and such. They're going to market it loads, this isn't a niche game.

Oh wii games get told that all the time haha.  But does it actually happen?  Not usually.  Really looking over 3rd party offerings on the Wii, there are very few I can comment on and say they had a well oiled and functioning hype/marketing machine.  Best one so far has been Monster Hunter 3 and it achieved awesome sales because of it.  Hopefully they'll carry that same marketing campaign to the west.  Others include Call of Duty: World at War (well over a million in sales), Red Steel (one of Wii's biggest launch titles), every Guitar Hero game (of course those were multiplay advertising), the Lego games (one again multiplat advertising), EA Sports Active (well over 2 million and ever growing), Mario and Sonic games (of course could be seen as first party game as well), and a few more that I'm probably forgetting.

 

Now look at these games.  All huge successes.  Wii games are no different than that of 360, PS3, PC, PSP, DS, etc.  For a videogame to be successful the advertising needs to sell it.  You rarely ever sell a game off of its own merit of existing (that's why Halo and Mario are still advertised along with popular brand such as Coke and Windows).  Most Wii games just dont' get that level of advertising while PS360 games and a few DS games do.  Could even throw PSP in that category as well.  As I've said numerous time sover, if Wii were to get the level of advertising as PS360 games (and the level of big brands) well over a 100 Wii games would have easily sold a million copies by now. 

Now when it comes to Epic Mickey, they are saying they are going to give it the advertising of a big game, but how many times have Wii games been told this and they not fulfill it.  Now they did get first entry through a GI cover so that's a start but I'm still skeptical and for good reason.  I hope Disney Interactive treats this like a huge game on the Wii but I hold my doubts.  I'll wait for E3 to see how they advertise this game.  I hope they collaborate with Ninty to get that as a frontrunner at their conference.