By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Sony - Unchated 2 or Modern Warfare 2 ?

S.T.A.G.E. on 12 November 2009
huaxiong90 said:
S.T.A.G.E. said:
huaxiong90 said:
Uncharted 2 has the "holy shit" graphics moments. Plus, the online is loads of fun, and it seems like it could last for quite a long time.

Wait...you're actually going to sit there and truthfully oversell Uncharteds multiplayer over MW2? OMG You PS3 guys are hilarious.

1. The game is only 10 hours long and survives off of the story alone.

2. The multiplayer is only a fad unlike MW2 which will last for years and is probably the best FPS experience the PS3 has got.

1. @the red: Ok, this needs to stop. The PS3 may be my preferred console this gen, but I'm just a gamer. I've no devotion to Sony whatsoever.

 

2. The MP being a fad unlike MW2, is purely your opinion. My favorite FPS this gen is BioShock, and nothing can change that opinion.

1. That is an old post, I know you better now and have gained quite a bit of respect for you as opposed to the past.

2. UC2's multiplayer is a fad. As I said, watch the PSN Top 10 games (if you can even find them) monthly and you'll see exactly what I am talking about. MW beat out Halo 3 for over a year and then Halo 3 took the reigns back and it was a back and forth war between them on Xbox Live. This is because the 360 has very strong multiplayer games where as Sonys strength is in single player titles. This exactly why I enjoy having both systems.



Around the Network
MasterZack on 12 November 2009

Uncharted by faaaaaaaaaaaaaar!!

Action games > FPS.



MY ZELDA COLLECTION
Staude on 12 November 2009
S.T.A.G.E. said:
Reasonable said:
S.T.A.G.E. said:

Uncharted 2 is too of a game linear to warrant a true purchase if the choice is between it and Modern Warfare 2. Modern Warfare has the multiplayer that will last years. Uncharted 2's multiplayer is good, but is going to play second fiddle to Modern Warfare online as that is currently the top shooter in sales and gameplay on the PS3.

What if you actually prefer SP to MP and prefer a superior script and voice acting?  Just curious?


This is actually a very good question which I would be more than happy to answer. I totally agree that some people prefer the single player experience to multiplayer; infact this is the very reason why I bought a PS3. I love the single player experience. I am stating that MW2 is a huge win for the PS3 in terms of what the exclusives seem to lack. As far as single player MW2 still plays more like a videogame with some movie elements. Uncharted is basically an action movie that allows you to feel portions of the excitement that exist within the world Drake lives in. Don't get me wrong, I loved both Uncharted games. My malfunction is I want the guy to get the most for his money and Uncharted 2 cannot compare to MW2 in longevity. I hope this makes some sense to you.

You know some people might actually prefere uncharteds multiplayer over cods. While I don't have mw2, I didn't like modern warfare 1's multiplayer. I do however like Uncharted 2's multiplayer.

 

For the record I also liked Cod with united offensives multiplayer.

And Zombie mode in cod waw.



Check out my game about moles ^

badgenome on 12 November 2009

Uncharted 2. It's fucking phenomenal, and Satan isn't the CEO of its publisher.



S.T.A.G.E. on 12 November 2009
Staude said:
S.T.A.G.E. said:
Reasonable said:
S.T.A.G.E. said:

Uncharted 2 is too of a game linear to warrant a true purchase if the choice is between it and Modern Warfare 2. Modern Warfare has the multiplayer that will last years. Uncharted 2's multiplayer is good, but is going to play second fiddle to Modern Warfare online as that is currently the top shooter in sales and gameplay on the PS3.

What if you actually prefer SP to MP and prefer a superior script and voice acting?  Just curious?


This is actually a very good question which I would be more than happy to answer. I totally agree that some people prefer the single player experience to multiplayer; infact this is the very reason why I bought a PS3. I love the single player experience. I am stating that MW2 is a huge win for the PS3 in terms of what the exclusives seem to lack. As far as single player MW2 still plays more like a videogame with some movie elements. Uncharted is basically an action movie that allows you to feel portions of the excitement that exist within the world Drake lives in. Don't get me wrong, I loved both Uncharted games. My malfunction is I want the guy to get the most for his money and Uncharted 2 cannot compare to MW2 in longevity. I hope this makes some sense to you.

You know some people might actually prefere uncharteds multiplayer over cods. While I don't have mw2, I didn't like modern warfare 1's multiplayer. I do however like Uncharted 2's multiplayer.

 

For the record I also liked Cod with united offensives multiplayer.

And Zombie mode in cod waw.

Yes....you're right my friend. Some people are the key words. Not enough to truly make  a difference is my point.



Around the Network
Staude on 12 November 2009

Well frankly it's too early to tell if uncharteds mp will have longlivity. ^



Check out my game about moles ^

S.T.A.G.E. on 12 November 2009
Staude said:

Well frankly it's too early to tell if uncharteds mp will have longlivity. ^

LOL....It's the PS3....just watch. I have a very good feeling about this from watching MGS4's results.



Adjudicator on 12 November 2009

It all comes down to if you prefer good SP or good MP both can hold their own in both aspects but they shine in one.
In my opinion U2 single player is better than MW2 multiplayer (if that makes any sense). But be warned I do generally prefer SP to MP so their might be some bias.



 

MakoInfused on 12 November 2009

according to your "holy shit" moment request, Uncharted2 is the way to go :D



Reasonable on 12 November 2009
S.T.A.G.E. said:
Reasonable said:
S.T.A.G.E. said:

Uncharted 2 is too of a game linear to warrant a true purchase if the choice is between it and Modern Warfare 2. Modern Warfare has the multiplayer that will last years. Uncharted 2's multiplayer is good, but is going to play second fiddle to Modern Warfare online as that is currently the top shooter in sales and gameplay on the PS3.

What if you actually prefer SP to MP and prefer a superior script and voice acting?  Just curious?


This is actually a very good question which I would be more than happy to answer. I totally agree that some people prefer the single player experience to multiplayer; infact this is the very reason why I bought a PS3. I love the single player experience. I am stating that MW2 is a huge win for the PS3 in terms of what the exclusives seem to lack. As far as single player MW2 still plays more like a videogame with some movie elements. Uncharted is basically an action movie that allows you to feel portions of the excitement that exist within the world Drake lives in. Don't get me wrong, I loved both Uncharted games. My malfunction is I want the guy to get the most for his money and Uncharted 2 cannot compare to MW2 in longevity. I hope this makes some sense to you.

Actually, i you read the majority of reviews, or look to those like me who play SP way more than MP, you'll see Uncharted 2 SP wipes the floor with MW2 SP.  MW2 is a good fps with a terrible campaign that is short, unfocused and actually has few really wow moments.  Uncharted 2 on the other hand is much longer, focused and has he most 'wow' moments of any SP campaign I've played in years.

In other words, MW2 is all about the MP, hell, it's obvious plenty of MW2 purchasers aren't even going to bother with the SP (apart from maybe trying out the now infamous Airport level) whereas with Uncharted 2 the SP is what pushed the games, with the coop and MP as a nice bonus.



Try to be reasonable... its easier than you think...