By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Sony - Uncharted 2 is now the greatest game of all time

Carl on 22 October 2009
selnor said:
There is NO such thing as best game ever. Why? Well someones faveourite genre might be beat em ups. No matter how many good reviews an action game might get, To the beat em up fan it will NEVER be the best game ever. Same goes for a racing enthusiast or an JRPG lover. Or a WRPG lover. OR a FPS lover or a TPS lover.

See my point.

Uncharted 2 falls into action/adventure. So it may be the best action/adventure game ever? But can never be the best game ever. There is no such thing.

I don't usually agree with you...

But i do on this one



                            

Around the Network
DarthRat on 22 October 2009

Uncharted 2 is a VERY GOOD game but Ocarina Of Time is still hailed as 'the best game ever' for the INNOVATIONS it brought to the gaming. It's a great game but I don't see how just taking the best of what has been done before and putting that together can be considered the best game ever personally.



selnor on 22 October 2009
Carl2291 said:
selnor said:
There is NO such thing as best game ever. Why? Well someones faveourite genre might be beat em ups. No matter how many good reviews an action game might get, To the beat em up fan it will NEVER be the best game ever. Same goes for a racing enthusiast or an JRPG lover. Or a WRPG lover. OR a FPS lover or a TPS lover.

See my point.

Uncharted 2 falls into action/adventure. So it may be the best action/adventure game ever? But can never be the best game ever. There is no such thing.

I don't usually agree with you...

But i do on this one

:))))))))



yo_john117 on 22 October 2009

It's not really up to you to say what game is the greatest of all time.



Steroid on 22 October 2009

Meh OOT isn't even the best Zelda game. It's over-rated because the N64 had a pretty crappy lineup compared to the SNES.



Around the Network
BMaker11 on 22 October 2009

Highest reviewed game.....geez



HideoK on 22 October 2009
selnor said:
There is NO such thing as best game ever. Why? Well someones faveourite genre might be beat em ups. No matter how many good reviews an action game might get, To the beat em up fan it will NEVER be the best game ever. Same goes for a racing enthusiast or an JRPG lover. Or a WRPG lover. OR a FPS lover or a TPS lover.

See my point.

Uncharted 2 falls into action/adventure. So it may be the best action/adventure game ever? But can never be the best game ever. There is no such thing.

Good point. Personally, I would rate it as the best action adventure game and one of the best games I've ever played.

Others might not like this genre as much as a TPS or JRPG so it wouldn't be their best game ever.



BladeOfGod on 22 October 2009

for me its the greatest game of all time

1. UNCHARTED 2
2. UNCHARTED 1
3. Resident Evil 4
4.God Of War 2

those are mine top 4 greatest games



BMaker11 on 22 October 2009

Question though:

Why is it that when GTAIV came out and was reviewing high, and was being called "The Greatest Game of All Time" because of said review scores, everyone got in a hubbub about it, and was actively seeking reviews that would lower the aggregate so that OoT would remain on top as the "Greatest Game of All Time".....now Uncharted 2 is on top, and now, there's "no such thing as the Greatest Game of All Time"???



justinian on 22 October 2009
Carl2291 said:
selnor said:
There is NO such thing as best game ever. Why? Well someones faveourite genre might be beat em ups. No matter how many good reviews an action game might get, To the beat em up fan it will NEVER be the best game ever. Same goes for a racing enthusiast or an JRPG lover. Or a WRPG lover. OR a FPS lover or a TPS lover.

See my point.

Uncharted 2 falls into action/adventure. So it may be the best action/adventure game ever? But can never be the best game ever. There is no such thing.

I don't usually agree with you...

But i do on this one

I second that. It's like asking what is the greatest dish (in terms of food) of all time.

BTW: Golden Eye 007 N64 is the greatest game of all time...IMO.

A lot of what is common in games today was inspired by GE 007.