By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Sony - Uncharted 2 EDGE review ! How could they ?

MontanaHatchet on 14 October 2009

Hear that guys? Slimebeast played the first Uncharted, and he's watched videos of the sequel! That means he's able to make judgments about the second game without having played it!

Man, genius and unbiased thinking prevails again.



 

 

Around the Network
room414 on 14 October 2009

I'm not complaining about the score but the fact that edge put uncharted2 on par with odst by giving both 9's  makes them a joke imo.



                                
Bagaren85 on 14 October 2009

lol.-



brianblair on 14 October 2009

I can't think of another game where people get legitimately mad at a 9/10 review. IMO, that's a great score (although I do think the game is a 10)



Reasonable on 14 October 2009

Wow, Edge manage to cause as much fuss as Forza 3 vs GT5 no matter what they do.

OT 9/10 seems good to me.



Try to be reasonable... its easier than you think...

Around the Network
Slimebeast on 14 October 2009
MontanaHatchet said:
Hear that guys? Slimebeast played the first Uncharted, and he's watched videos of the sequel! That means he's able to make judgments about the second game without having played it!

Man, genius and unbiased thinking prevails again.

lol...

 

CGI-Quality said:
Slimebeast said:
CGI-Quality said:
Slimebeast said:
CGI-Quality said:
Slimebeast said:
I agree with 9.

This would make sense if you had an experience with the game. Have you played it yet?

No, but I can feel it's a fair score.

But how though? You haven't played the game....

That's like me saying I think a 5/10 is fair for Damnation even though I've yet to play it. If you nsaid you don't see how a 9 is a bad grade, or an irrational one, I'd be fine. To say it's "fair" is out of place, you have no experience for the game. Also, weren't you the one claiming people were "biased" for giving certain grades to games that you favor and you BELIEVED that others hadn't played. That's all I'm saying.

You are correct.

Let's put it this way. From looking at the videos (and myself actually having played the first uncharted until the plane crash) and reading other sources I have a hunch that it's a fair score.

You have a hunch, cool, then when people give games, that YOU favor, scores you deem unfair, a post from you will be out of place. Be real about it...Again, that's all I'm getting at...

I don't understand what you're trying to say. But I'm always real.



Slimebeast on 14 October 2009
axumblade said:
Slimebeast said:
CGI-Quality said:
Slimebeast said:
CGI-Quality said:
Slimebeast said:
I agree with 9.

This would make sense if you had an experience with the game. Have you played it yet?

No, but I can feel it's a fair score.

But how though? You haven't played the game....

That's like me saying I think a 5/10 is fair for Damnation even though I've yet to play it. If you nsaid you don't see how a 9 is a bad grade, or an irrational one, I'd be fine. To say it's "fair" is out of place, you have no experience for the game. Also, weren't you the one claiming people were "biased" for giving certain grades to games that you favor and you BELIEVED that others hadn't played. That's all I'm saying.

You are correct.

Let's put it this way. From looking at the videos (and myself actually having played the first uncharted until the plane crash) and reading other sources I have a hunch that it's a fair score.

Until the plane crash.....You missed out on a lot....x.x

Yes, but I will buy the game after I've got the Slim. Unlike starcraft who rents these games.



joshin69 on 14 October 2009
Slimebeast said:
MontanaHatchet said:
Hear that guys? Slimebeast played the first Uncharted, and he's watched videos of the sequel! That means he's able to make judgments about the second game without having played it!

Man, genius and unbiased thinking prevails again.

lol...

 

CGI-Quality said:
Slimebeast said:
CGI-Quality said:
Slimebeast said:
CGI-Quality said:
Slimebeast said:
I agree with 9.

This would make sense if you had an experience with the game. Have you played it yet?

No, but I can feel it's a fair score.

But how though? You haven't played the game....

That's like me saying I think a 5/10 is fair for Damnation even though I've yet to play it. If you nsaid you don't see how a 9 is a bad grade, or an irrational one, I'd be fine. To say it's "fair" is out of place, you have no experience for the game. Also, weren't you the one claiming people were "biased" for giving certain grades to games that you favor and you BELIEVED that others hadn't played. That's all I'm saying.

You are correct.

Let's put it this way. From looking at the videos (and myself actually having played the first uncharted until the plane crash) and reading other sources I have a hunch that it's a fair score.

You have a hunch, cool, then when people give games, that YOU favor, scores you deem unfair, a post from you will be out of place. Be real about it...Again, that's all I'm getting at...

I don't understand what you're trying to say. But I'm always real.

Wow, I smell Ass gravy.



 

 assumption is the mother of all f**k ups 

Carl on 14 October 2009

Hey guys!

This review is the one that has lowered the score to a 96!

How predictable



                            

NicholasCage on 14 October 2009

Same score as ODST. Not bad.



Battlefield Bad Company 2 > Modern Warfare 2