By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Sony - Uncharted 2 EDGE review ! How could they ?

MetalGearSolid_4ever on 14 October 2009
Rainbird said:
MetalGearSolid_4ever said:
starcraft said:
Edge aren't biased. Their general score history proves this.

PS3 fans are just sore because Edge believes Halo 3 is better than Uncharted 2.

Um.no.

EDGE have not said Halo 3 > Uncharted 2. You cant just assume stuff like that man !

Having said that though, Edge are HALO fanboys though..its obvious. And they have some problems with inconsistent scoring of their reviews.

Not just PS3 exclusives, games such as Mass Effect, Bioshock, etc. did not get what they deserve.

That's your opinion. If Edge doesn't think as highly of them as you do, then that's your opinion versus theirs. No one wins or loses...


their review scores are usually way lower than the aggregate score. just saying.

Around the Network
MetalGearSolid_4ever on 14 October 2009
Dazzle said:
am i missing something here.. that looks like a pretty good score..

It is an awesome score. I'm just saying that its unlike EDGE to give such a score.

Acevil on 14 October 2009
MetalGearSolid_4ever said:
Rainbird said:
MetalGearSolid_4ever said:
starcraft said:
Edge aren't biased. Their general score history proves this.

PS3 fans are just sore because Edge believes Halo 3 is better than Uncharted 2.

Um.no.

EDGE have not said Halo 3 > Uncharted 2. You cant just assume stuff like that man !

Having said that though, Edge are HALO fanboys though..its obvious. And they have some problems with inconsistent scoring of their reviews.

Not just PS3 exclusives, games such as Mass Effect, Bioshock, etc. did not get what they deserve.

That's your opinion. If Edge doesn't think as highly of them as you do, then that's your opinion versus theirs. No one wins or loses...

their review scores are usually way lower than the aggregate score. just saying.

That is because Edge uses the Traditional Scoring system that most critics use (5 being average). Video game critics uses a totaly different system where 7 or 7.5 is Average.



 

Staude on 14 October 2009
Rainbird said:
starcraft said:
Edge aren't biased. Their general score history proves this.

PS3 fans are just sore because Edge believes Halo 3 is better than Uncharted 2.

Lol, a better example would probably have been a game we haven't just recieved the score for

And it is a shame that many PS3 fans seem to be giving Edge a hard time for no reason >_>

The problem with edge is their inconsistency.

 

On topic.. I thought the OP was sarcastic. I don't think i've ever seen a edge score for a ps3 game higher than 8 lol :p



Check out my game about moles ^

Acevil on 14 October 2009
Staude said:
Rainbird said:
starcraft said:
Edge aren't biased. Their general score history proves this.

PS3 fans are just sore because Edge believes Halo 3 is better than Uncharted 2.

Lol, a better example would probably have been a game we haven't just recieved the score for

And it is a shame that many PS3 fans seem to be giving Edge a hard time for no reason >_>

The problem with edge is their inconsistency.

 

On topic.. I thought the OP was sarcastic. I don't think i've ever seen a edge score for a ps3 game higher than 8 lol :p

Hopefully you were being sarcastic since they gave LBP 10.



 

Around the Network
Rainbird on 14 October 2009
MetalGearSolid_4ever said:
Rainbird said:
MetalGearSolid_4ever said:
starcraft said:
Edge aren't biased. Their general score history proves this.

PS3 fans are just sore because Edge believes Halo 3 is better than Uncharted 2.

Um.no.

EDGE have not said Halo 3 > Uncharted 2. You cant just assume stuff like that man !

Having said that though, Edge are HALO fanboys though..its obvious. And they have some problems with inconsistent scoring of their reviews.

Not just PS3 exclusives, games such as Mass Effect, Bioshock, etc. did not get what they deserve.

That's your opinion. If Edge doesn't think as highly of them as you do, then that's your opinion versus theirs. No one wins or loses...

their review scores are usually way lower than the aggregate score. just saying.

Edge and Eurogamer are the only review instances I know who aren't afraid to use '5' as average, where as most other sites will give average games 6-7 as a minimum. Aggregate scores are usually inflated because of the system, if you ask me.



chasmatic12 on 14 October 2009

Gotta love the meltdown at N4G. It's sad when gamers take a 9 as a bad sign.



wholikeswood on 14 October 2009

Haha, I bet they gave a 9 through gritted teeth.

Blatantly wanted to give it a 7.



Staude on 14 October 2009
Acevil said:
Staude said:
Rainbird said:
starcraft said:
Edge aren't biased. Their general score history proves this.

PS3 fans are just sore because Edge believes Halo 3 is better than Uncharted 2.

Lol, a better example would probably have been a game we haven't just recieved the score for

And it is a shame that many PS3 fans seem to be giving Edge a hard time for no reason >_>

The problem with edge is their inconsistency.

 

On topic.. I thought the OP was sarcastic. I don't think i've ever seen a edge score for a ps3 game higher than 8 lol :p

Hopefully you were being sarcastic since they gave LBP 10.

lol well i don't really have time to read all their reviews :p I was simply stating that I have not. As in ME.. Seen them give a score higher than a 8 to a ps3 game. Now I know they have.



Check out my game about moles ^

MetalGearSolid_4ever on 14 October 2009
chasmatic12 said:
Gotta love the meltdown at N4G. It's sad when gamers take a 9 as a bad sign.

GOOD LORD ! Im saying that 9/10 from EDGE is awesome ! Sarcasm meters have taken a huge hit in this thread !

GOTY 2009 confirmed.