I love people saying it's a copy of gears and tomb raider. Makes it obvious that you have never played Uncharted. The games are totally different.

it plays exactly like Gears of War and have simillar setting and style to Tomb Raider series - so i guess calling it Gears of War/Tomb Raider mix is RIGHT(especially since it copied huge part of GoWs multiplayer this time around as well).

Why is it only the PS3 fans cry constantly about bias on sites, I think you guys really need to grow up and face the fact you may actually be talking crap. 9.3 is a great score and the points made were fair, nothing good can come further from this topic it should be locked.

And Gears of War Is just a rip of Resident Evil 4 and Halo 3 is pretty much a clone of Halo 1-2 (it literally uses the same engine as Halo 2), see what I did thar? but for some reason a lot of 360 fanboys are pretending that these games are the most original things ever created. They aren't.

And pretty much everyone knows that dude Shane is a stelth X-Bot, it's public knowledge.

Well, I am listing to Invisible Walls now, and they are just stupid. They say the value and originality are the most important points, but pretty much every idea has already been done. Even LBP had kind of been done before, but it is just done a lot better this time! But I guess all I can do is wait for the game to release and then make a full judgement then

Haha you're just proving my point about never having played it. It doesn't play like gears at all... 2 totally different styles. Can you even jump in gears? Hang off ledges? Setting similar to Tomb Raider? As I said you have no idea. How did it copy god of war? Maybe you mean GeOW. But you do know that copied other games right?

From what I played of the 2 games they were totally different online. But I only played one game of GeOW 2. Couldn't get used to the way the character controls but since it plays "exactly" like Uncharted I guess I can't play that either.... Oh wait. It doesn't. The characters are a lot heavier in the way they move. Kind of like killzone 2 compared to halo 3. 

Don't bother proving that you haven't played Uncharted again. We already know you haven't from your responses. And if you did I don't understand how you can think they play the same since they go for 2 totally different things. The games feel and play the way that they look. Normal characters vs over muscled characters.

This is hilarious.

17 pages of whinging and WHY ?

Because a game site loved a game, but didnt love it enough for people to be happy.

good lord,,,,now a 9.3 needs explanation?

what is wrong with some fanboys??(i mean the ones who have objected to 9.3 on their site)

it's just a freakin game that they thought it was really awesome.

I haven't read every page in this thread but IMO their comment is discussion worthy (I don't understand why some people criticize people bringing forward valid points), to requote myself:

IMO the weird inconsistent reasoning here was of Gamespot / Eurogamer (UK) - like proportions...

I hope GT with the criticism will be able to reflect upon itself and their history of reasoning. I would like to see more consistency from them, they are an important source for information.

9.3 is a good score so I'm wondering why this is even an issue, unless the main people complaining are the crazy people at gametrailers. P

"be happy we said buy it if you have a ps3"??? Looks like Uncharted 3 will have to add dual wielding to get a higher score :P