I prefer the way Uncharted 2 handles it where it can be more accurate to blindfire shoot if you have the right skill. I do not like the way COD forces you to use the reticle.

wow I thought it would beat MGS4.....looks like it won't anymore

I'm going to guess that won't be counted.

@kantor

why not?

he can't possibly be a fanboy as this is a multiplat game

thats his opinion kantor, I found COD4 very boring

the guy has atleast given valid reasons unlike some people in this thread who gave a 9 & didn't write reasons

Yes, but giving a game a 3 is just ridiculous. Very few games reach that level of suckiness, and CoD4 is not one of them. Really, it's not even subjective. I mean, give it a 7 or 8, even a 6, but 3 implies that it is so horrendous as to be unplayable.

EDIT: Maybe he's a Wii fanboy! But it's releasing on Wii as well so does that work?

9.5

+Best online EVAH (I've played Halo (not extensively))
+Sweet graphics (for when it was released)
+Still has the best sound engine
+Gameplay mechanics are nearly perfect
+Perks
+Single player sniper mission

-Rubbish story
-Grenades are overused online
-Single player too short
-Annoying griefing online

@Kantor

he may be a SEGA fanboy you know!

9.4

10 of course

the best multiplayer online i've played in a long time. sucks my life away as I try to get to the top prestige. brilliant mix of rpg stuff like xp and challenges etc, with a shooter, and its so fast to get in a game. unlike halo or gears. the game you want asap.

perfect, and im scared to think mw 2 may be a letdown somehow, but probobly not.

single player sucked obviously, but the only people i know who bought this game for that are on this site.

even if the single player was so bad it could red ring my xbox for 3 days, id still say ten with that multiplayer.

10/10 seriously the best FPS i've played on consoles.