By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - General Discussion - Mafia Round 5B- Game Thread

Gnizmo said:
WoW appears to be the cop, but I think he is insane. Trust me when I say hat WoW would have been the first one I offed if I was mafia. You take out the people who are most dangerous first, and he is clearly the top of the list. hat said we don't have much more to go on, and no lynch on day two might not work out so well.

I was waiting for this. 

I'm not the cop so I can't be insane, I'm a different investigative role.

You will be lynched today because you are mafia.



Around the Network
Words Of Wisdom said:

I was waiting for this.

I'm not the cop so I can't be insane, I'm a different investigative role.

You will be lynched today because you are mafia.

Well then I have to assume you are the tracker. All you know for certain is who I targetted, but not why. The schpele is a nice way to convince people you must know I am mafia when you really only have that I targetted someone. Again, if I were mafia then you would be dead. Investigating someone would appear the same as targeting them to kill in your eyes though, no?



Starcraft 2 ID: Gnizmo 229

I normally like to play cat and mouse about role claims, but I will be gone most of the day so I can't really. Yes, I am claiming cop. No, I am not certain if I am sane or naive. Yes, I invetigated dtewi. Mafia lurking have an inherent advatange of no slip-ups. No, he wasn't mafia.

Edited for gross spelling errors caused by a low battery wireless keyboard. Since I am long out of the game all it does is make me look less stupid.



Starcraft 2 ID: Gnizmo 229

Gnizmo said:
I normally lke tlay ca and ouse about role claims, but I will be gone most of the day so I can't really. Yes, I am claiming cop. No, I am not certain if I am sane or naive. Yes, I invetigated dtewi. Mafia lurking have an inherent advatange of no slip-ups. No, he wasn't mafia.

You're not the cop.  You're only claiming the cop role because we've had multiple cops and you think you can get away with it.  You won't.

Your first lie was to say I was insane, your second lie has been false roleclaiming.  You're running out of lies to tell.

You are mafia and we will lynch you today.



Sadly, I don't believe you, Gnizmo, your cop confession is too forced. WoW's claim makes sense, if she's the tracker/watcher, then Gnizmo targeted dtewi

Vote: Gnizmo




Around the Network
axumblade said:
insomniac17 said:
He could be a watcher, who targets a player to see who else targeted that player last night, or he could be a tracker who targets a player to see who they targeted that night.

A vigilante is a town aligned killer, basically. He can choose someone to kill at night; the thing is that he is town aligned. So, we lost a pretty powerful ally with dtewi's death.

Well, I'm not going to lie, I was going to vote to lynch him tonight since he hasn't bothered even posting in the thread, much less even confirm that he wanted to be in the game.

I don't blame you. He doesn't need to post a lot, but it would be great if he had confirmed that he was ready. Maybe something's come up, who knows? We don't have to worry about it now, though I'm sure he'll come back and be very indignant at being killed off before he got to do anything.

@ Gnizmo; I do have to say that you're looking pretty suspicious right now.

The way I see it, there are a few possible scenarios; Gnizmo is a cop who investigated dtewi, or Gnizmo is mafia who killed dtewi. Honestly, either WoW is playing a very clever game or is telling the truth. I'm inclined to believe the latter, at least for now. If WoW was in fact mafia, then how would he have known that Gnizmo also targeted dtewi (which we know that he did, since he's basically confirmed it). The only way that would work was if WoW was mafia and was targeting fellow mafia member Gnizmo. For now though, I'll go with my gut.

Vote: Gnizmo



Since I can't edit, I apologize for posting two times in a row, but I want to add something.

Gnizmo said:
WoW appears to be the cop, but I think he is insane. Trust me when I say hat WoW would have been the first one I offed if I was mafia. You take out the people who are most dangerous first, and he is clearly the top of the list. hat said we don't have much more to go on, and no lynch on day two might not work out so well.

If WoW was the cop, then there was no way that he would have known that Gnizmo also targeted dtewi. WoW can't be the cop. I'm not sure if this was a slip or not, but he said "WoW appears to be the cop." So, if we take this as true, then he believes that there is only one cop, and believed that the cop was WoW. That would make his role claim false.

I may be looking a bit too much into that, but I thought I'd throw it out there. Also, Gnizmo could be playing a very clever game in killing off the guy who hasn't posted yet, and then claiming that if he was mafia, he would kill WoW right away because WoW is such a threat.



insomniac17 said:

The way I see it, there are a few possible scenarios; Gnizmo is a cop who investigated dtewi, or Gnizmo is mafia who killed dtewi. Honestly, either WoW is playing a very clever game or is telling the truth. I'm inclined to believe the latter, at least for now. If WoW was in fact mafia, then how would he have known that Gnizmo also targeted dtewi (which we know that he did, since he's basically confirmed it). The only way that would work was if WoW was mafia and was targeting fellow mafia member Gnizmo. For now though, I'll go with my gut.

Vote: Gnizmo

Exactly. And even if that happens, lynching Gnizmo makes it a win for us. I think the odds of WoW guessing who Gnizmo targeted are horribly low, so we have to trust that Gnizmo targeted dtewi (which he's not denying). And since dtewi is now dead, then the most logical choice is lynching. There are two options, either WoW is tracker and Gnizmo is mafia, or WoW is bluffing, she got increidibly lucky and Gnizmo is innocent. I'll use Occam's Razor here, and say that the option we gotta choose is the first




Wow, this is interesting turn of events. Sorry Gnizmo, WoW's case is good. Very good.

Vote: Gnizmo.



"We'll toss the dice however they fall,
And snuggle the girls be they short or tall,
Then follow young Mat whenever he calls,
To dance with Jak o' the Shadows."

Check out MyAnimeList and my Game Collection. Owner of the 5 millionth post.

Person Voting To Lynch ( Lynched | Murdered ) Identity

Day 1
Day 2 Day 3 Day 4 Day 5 Day 6  
Zexen_lowe No Lynch
Gnizmo
     
Gnizmo No Lynch
         
Dgc1808 No Lynch
Gnizmo        
Axumblade
No Lynch
Gnizmo
         
Falcon095 (no vote)


     
Soriku
No Lynch
 

     
c03n3nj0 No Lynch

 
       
Words Of Wisdom No Lynch Gnizmo
       
insomniac17 No Lynch Gnizmo          
outlawauron No Lynch Gnizmo
         
dtewi (no vote) --- --- --- --- --- Vigilante