Wow...this list isnt bad. RE5 for sure. Alone int he dark...indeed. Doom 3...agreed.

I never got in to able so I can't comment.

CGI-Quality said: I can't speak for Fable II, unfortunately because I haven't played it , but RE5 wasn't so much a let down as it was a different twist on Resident Evil. I'd prefer the horror elements to return...

It's quite obvious Capcom just wanted money, thank god Alan Wake is coming out is all I have to say!

RE5 obviously disappointed CORE RE fanbase......the main character having controls & movements like a oversized tank didn't help either.

RE5 metacritic over 85 for both version, sold over 5million copies, Yeah it lived up to its hype.

@psrock

but do people remember it

is its name taken in a single GOTY thread

look RE5 is the sequel to what some say is the best game of last gen & game thats in the top 10 games on metacritic (RE4).....on that front, hell yeah it was a disappointment.....going from a 94 + rating to 85

Almost very Resident Evil game has been a staple of gaming for years to come. Well not every one...RE1, RE2, RE Remake and RE4.

Resident Evil 5 is one of the most disposable games ever made. Fun, right here...right now...but pretty flawed to begin with and totally off the rader tomorrow.

I'd consider that a dissapointment especially after the glorious RE4...

I disagree.

I don't think RE5 should be on the list at all [well atleast not in the top 3]. Sure, it wasn't the best game ever at survival horror, but it was a damn good action game imo.

Also Moleneux does overhype a lot. But the fable still ends up very good. Fable 2 was a very solid game and I'm sure it disappointed VERY FEW fans.

EDITED 

Red Steel was awesome! nuff said

The King of fighters xii

Fear 2

Lair

The Conduit

Haze

It's still a good game and tons of people still wish it was on their console, and if it did they would buy just like in the HD console.