I disagree.
I don't think RE5 should be on the list at all [well atleast not in the top 3]. Sure, it wasn't the best game ever at survival horror, but it was a damn good action game imo.
Also Moleneux does overhype a lot. But the fable still ends up very good. Fable 2 was a very solid game and I'm sure it disappointed VERY FEW fans.
EDITED
4 ≈ One







