I voted for him last round so I obviously like him, but I just like Sonic better as an icon, I still boot up Sonic Adventure 1 and 2 on DC but I only beat FF7 2 times /shrug and I also can't count the amount of time I've spent on 2D Sonic games, when you put all that together, Sephiroth does not win in my book this round since he's pretty much just been in a bunch of other spin off games or as a spin off character.

Sephiroth all the way !

Sonic.
I'm not really a fan of his, but I do prefer him over Sephiroth.

Sonic

@Blacksaber- your a sega fanboy?! uh oh... well i am to! i swear! just not when its against t3h one winged angel! :D

@da- Same here, Sonic Advenutre DX on Gamecube though and Sonic Adventure 2 EB also on gamecube, i never got to own a dreamcast my self but it was such a great console. but im talking now an days, for example Sephiroth in Dissidia: Final Fantasy has got to be the best hes ever been in anygame, and hes not a spin off in there hes a full character. :0

And as for the original FFVII, i've beaten it over 58 times, and yes i've kept track in my old gaming tablet that i found lol, its most likely the only JRPG game i've played to many times.

But as for sonic, i can't name one game hes been in as of late thats been counted as good, the werehog one was good but its that very "Innovation" that made kinda not good.

Hopfully that new side-scrolling one thats coming out in early 10 will be good and return to the good ol' days when he was awesome.

Til' then though i feel my sephiroth over sonic vote is rather just' if that. :D

Sonic

Sepiroth

It doesn't really matter, because Link is going to win either way.

Part of me wants to put Sephiroth in there, because he's from a Sony game. But then part of me wants to actually follow the rules.

The second part wins. I vote...Sonic.

Sonic.

Dissidia is a spin off game dood, he's not much a gaming icon, I do like his character of course. He was the main villian in FF7 where he wasn't a spin off character in a spin off game, rest of the times, he was always a spin off kinda character, it's the same way with Cloud and blahblah, that's just how SE does things these days, and it's starting to get annoying. I also happen to enjoy the Wii version of Unleashed quiet a bit, the day lvls anyways, werehog is a piece of shit, didn't like the HD version as much but meh. I loath Black Knight though, my god.... but Sonic still has accomplished more than the LS dood over the years.

I also don't know how you can beat FF7 58 times because the first time I beat the game at about lvl 60 then second time it was a 100% lvl 99 full materia run then I was done, I had like 20-30 other games I had to beat so I moved on lol.