I thought it was an nice vid.  It doesn't feel wrong.

The video doesn't go fast enough.

Nancy Drew? What the hell?


Good list though, including Snake, Link, and Mario.

I don't agree with number 1 though.

Thank god crash bandicoot wasn't there, top 10,000 by the skin of his teeth at best.

I scratched my head a little with number one (and Nancy Drew) but they were explained well, could not disagree with the reasoning really.

I was more surprised that Sonic was voted as biggest gaming Icon on MSN and in the UK...

Crash should have been in the place of ND, but its still a good list... totally agree with the top 2 spots tough

I was actually impressed by the reasons they gave for each character. Usually the reasoning in these types of lists is lacking.

Wow i don't know why they had nancy drew in there, I never even knew they had videogams based on her.  And lack of Master Chief is disturbing (he should have been in the place of nancy Drew)  But overall its a pretty good list.

Wow this list is pretty good. Nancy Drew is a bit weird and I'd switch 1 and 2 but no real complaints.

I see a couple of people wanting to remove Nancy Drew in favor of Master Chief, but based on the reasoning given in the video I think it would have to be Duke Nukem who was removed to get Master Chief into the list. I also think that Master Chief is a bit too new to be considered so influential just yet.

I also thought Nancy Drew was a strange choice, but the reasons are sound, and I can't come up with anything else that fits.