I did not see pikmin anywhere on the list I guess you are all don't care for a cult classic

pretty good list, i think OoT deserved its spot.

Half the list was Nintendo
OoT, IMO doesn't deserve to be in the top 10 [was never impressed with the game when I was playing it....]
MGS3 was too low...
I can't remember Golden Sun if memory serves, wasn't in the top 20... that saddened me....

Zelda OOT can't compete with MGS4

My only disappointments in the list were the absence of Ico, that SotC didn't crack the top ten, and I wanted Earthbound higher. That's about it, I don't really remember any games that didn't deserve to be on the list but were, would've been nice if we could keep all the current gen stuff off a list like that until we get some time with them. I really think that any list like that should never include current gen software.

OoT best game without a doubt. wasnt too bad overall... HL2 was far to low, MGS4 was far to high. Other then that it was pretty decent

I can't argue.

Good list is all I need to say.

I was disappointed at the lack of classic games on the list; there is nothing on the list that predates the Super Mario Bros, and in my (obviously biased) opinion that severely diminishes the worth of this list.