Castlevania: Symphony of the Night didn't make the list. Need I say more?

Oh yeah...that was such a good PSX game. I loved the whole deal with the inverted castle....man..didn't figure that out till a few years ago

Shadow of the Colossus wasn't number 1, so that was a problem.
ICO wasn't even on it, which is blasphemy.

Relatively decent overall though.
With it being a community list you can't ask for much more.

i disagree only with MGS4, it's not the 4th best game ever, for god's sake....

I recommened putting a link to the list (or all of them perhaps) in the OP, I myself am not completely used to VGChartz 2.0 (no, that's not an attempt at moaning it's crap, it's a fair improvement), so directing around is pretty hard. I imagine many others also share those problems.

So, finding it might prove difficult, but a link can solve all that.

Top 10: http://news.vgchartz.com/news.php?id=3742

Top 20: http://news.vgchartz.com/news.php?id=3700

Also, just a hint: Don't comment stuff like "SMG does NOT deserve 5th, it's just a SM64 rehash" or "MGS4? LULZ" if you haven't played the game. It'll shine through, and you will only make a fool of yourself.

MGS4 was way too high, no Symphony of the Night.

Besides that I didn't really have a problem with it.

It was a popularity contest. No hard feelings.

Someone want to do a % breakdown of which console, developer, genre, and generation each game came from? It could be an interesting look at the VGChartz demographic. I would do it but I have to......stand over there.

Of course you would!

Both GTA III and GTA Vice City were not on the list, but GTA IV was >.>

pong should have been the automatic #1 for starting the video game industry (not to say space war wasn't great though..)