By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Sales - Nintendos Disruption Strategy and all the rest are falling into the trap!

mrstickball said:
NJ5 said:
mrstickball said:
For such an uncompleted project, I don't see the Wiimote as being entirely disruptive.

We're 3 years in, and the only hailed games using the WiiMote are casual games. For disruption to happen, I'd think you not only need to disrupt what a gamer is (which Nintendo has done), but also bring vets into the fold, which Nintendo has certainly NOT done.

3 years, and I'm still waiting on an RPG that I can purchase a Wii for. Looks like NATAL may even beat them to the punch.

Wow, those are some sweeping generalizations. There are plenty of great non-casual games on the Wii which use the Wiimote well. And how did you conclude "vets certainly didn't come into the fold"?

 

@JGarrett: I don't usually think in these terms (of disruption, upstream, etc).

Nevertheless, I don't see why Nintendo would specifically take aim at the upstream (if upstream means HD-graphics lovers). They're expensive customers, and Nintendo's current platforms aren't about high specs. After the success of the Wii, it seems pretty proven that Nintendo can do well with moderate advances in graphics, and I don't see them changing their strategy.

 

Vets aren't coming aboard, because the HD twins are still selling rather well. Much better than any 2nd or 3rd place console has in history. This points to the fact that the market has been expanded, with the PS3/X360 getting much of the PS2/XB's core audience from last gen. That's not to say that 0% of console owners of last gen own a Wii, outside of GC owners, but I'd bet my house that the Wii has a vastly higher adoption rate by new gamers compared to the X360/PS3.

http://www.vgchartz.com/forum/post.php?id=1643973

I saved that link for just such an occasion.  Aparently, the NPD says that 70% of Wii owners also own a PS2.  Those sound like vets to me, and it doesn't even take into account those who only owned a GC last generation.  I would expect that to be fairly sizable as well.



Switch Code: SW-7377-9189-3397 -- Nintendo Network ID: theRepublic -- Steam ID: theRepublic

Now Playing
Switch - Super Mario Maker 2 (2019)
3DS - Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney (Trilogy) (2005/2014)
Mobile - Yugioh Duel Links (2017)
Mobile - Super Mario Run (2017)
PC - Borderlands 2 (2012)
PC - Deep Rock Galactic (2020)

Around the Network
BladeOfGod said:
Showertea said:

I don't think you understand Disruption. 

Disruptive games are like Wii Sports. Wii Sports will never be highly rated, because all the game reviewers are 'hardcore'.Hardcore doesnt mean gamers who only play mature games. No, but damned if there aren't a lot of them that think a game does have to be rated M to be good. Look at the people who started bashing Conduit because it got a T rating. ... And instead of Baseball, make it God of War.AGAIN, you DONT know what harcore gamers means For that matter, nor do you. There are so many subsets of gamers that it can't be described without getting into a mini discertation. And given where this thread is, I'd rather not do that, since it would fall on mostly deaf ears. (Or would that be blind eyes in this case?)

...Gran Turismo has better, more realistic graphics, but you play it using a joystick, which is completely unnatural and unrealistic.And it still sold about 50 million copies (entire franchise ) Which took it 7 games to do. Here's a tip for you: if you're going to make an argument, make sure it can't be shot down as easily as the other series selling more (~62 million) with a smaller number (6) of games.

...

I honestly don't think Gran Turismo 5 or Forza 3 are going to sell well. They don't have motion control.Hmmm...GTAIV and COD4 sold above 10 million (2 consoles combiend) and they DONT have motion controll.Weird I guess this proves you didn't even read the entire post, rather, you only responded to what you think you could. If you were paying attention, this post was talking about the current disruption to the racing category. Mario Kart Wii (and for that matter, MKDS) has outsold any single GT game, and as I mentioned prior, has more series sales. Neither GTA4 nor COD4's sales are relevant in terms of the RACING genre, which is the part you convienently ignored. Thus, the prediction of GT5 and Forza 3 having relatively poor sales. And if Sony and MS want to retake those genres, they're going to have to move to the expanded market,you mean casual makret (the market which is changeing very very fast) No, actually, 'expanded' is the correct word. Nintendo has created more people interested in racing games, thus expanding its market. They are branded as "casual" because of the reluctance of the old guard not willing to change their playstyle. They started playing because of the expansion techniques Nintendo used. Yes, if Sony or MS wants to take the crown back for, in this case, racing games, they will need to find some way to more even more compelling to this new market, or do something else drastic to get even more outsiders into gaming. Though at the same time, if they were to do that, I'm sure you'd not be so apt to call those new gamers casual, because they're on "your side." where their previous advantages (super awesome graphics) become liabilities (high price and large size 360 is cheper than Wii, lol). At retail, yes. But at wholesale? We don't have all the figures, just a lot of speculation, but the speculation seems to agree that the $200 X360 is sold at or just below cost. Meanwhile, Nintendo is making serious money on the Wii. At some point, I may crunch the numbers, but most would agree that Nintendo could sell the Wii for profit at $200. Thus making the Wii cheaper to produce, which is the advantage that this post was getting at. The higher cost to produce the X360, while still lower than the PS3, is still a liability for the system.

Oh, and BTW, only bolding your reply with no other change makes it rather tough to pick out.

 



-dunno001

-On a quest for the truly perfect game; I don't think it exists...

Demotruk said:
theprof00 said:
something like Metroid other M.

That's not upstreaming at all... nothing like it. (unless it uses Wii M+, we don't know that yet)

 

If you want to argue about Nintendo making stuff you want, that's a totally different discussion, we're talking about disruption as a business strategy that Nintendo is undertaking.

 Maybe the definition in the OP is wrong.

Metroid other M is the kind of game xbox and ps3 owners value, while integrating the values of Nintendo at the same time.

And let's face it, 3rd parties look at what Nintendo is doing and copy it. Nintendo is the most successful in the games area, so 3rd parties will naturally seek to mimic the games for similar sales numbers. This goes for consumers too. Most tend to stick by Nintendo. For this reason, until Nintendo makes a effort in content, not hardware, the wii cannot upstream.

 



Pyro as Bill said:
theprof00 said:
....... I would really love for Nintendo to come out next gen with an HD console and up the storage capacity and give me games with the length and content and maturity I want, no, need. It makes me giddy to think about it. Nintendo could totally destroy everyone next gen if they did it....


The next console will be HD.

Storage capacity? Can't say it's my highest priority but I'm sure it will be more than 20GB.

Length and content and maturity? You mean you want to pretend to be some kind of soldier, just say it.

I'm confident Nintendo will destroy everything next gen.

Not at all. I would simply like some characters I can identify with. It feels like everyone in a Nintendo game is super happy and saccharine. Third parties are the only ones that are appealing to me, and they're shit scared to release anything with too much production.



theprof00 said:

 Maybe the definition in the OP is wrong.

Metroid other M is the kind of game xbox and ps3 owners value, while integrating the values of Nintendo at the same time.

And let's face it, 3rd parties look at what Nintendo is doing and copy it. Nintendo is the most successful in the games area, so 3rd parties will naturally seek to mimic the games for similar sales numbers. This goes for consumers too. Most tend to stick by Nintendo. For this reason, until Nintendo makes a effort in content, not hardware, the wii cannot upstream.

 

The original post didn't define upstreaming, it used the word once and you seem to have inferred the wrong meaning from it. No, it's not about integrating the values of the old market. The key to disruption is not merely gaining new values, but abandoning old ones.



A game I'm developing with some friends:

www.xnagg.com/zombieasteroids/publish.htm

It is largely a technical exercise but feedback is appreciated.

Around the Network

I can see Wii will be here for long time. Don't need Wii 2 and no need for graphics upgrade. Just need new accessories.



You are correct I did misunderstand it. Disruption is simply changing the market into something else.
I see. Well then, rest assured that now this definitely will not happen. Because those people who bought 360 and ps3 bought them for the games, not motion control. As long as sony and MS continue to make the kinds of games they do, without opposition, there will be no disruption.



theprof00 said:
You are correct I did misunderstand it. Disruption is simply changing the market into something else. 
I see. Well then, rest assured that now this definitely will not happen. Because those people who bought 360 and ps3 bought them for the games, not motion control. As long as sony and MS continue to make the kinds of games they do, without opposition, there will be no disruption.

You continue to misunderstand it with your refusal to think in anything but simplistic terms. Disruption is not "simply" anything, it is a specifically outlined strategy, with one of the results being a change in the nature of the market.



A game I'm developing with some friends:

www.xnagg.com/zombieasteroids/publish.htm

It is largely a technical exercise but feedback is appreciated.

You're saying the disruption already occurred?



"As long as sony and MS continue to make the kinds of games they do, without opposition, there will be no disruption."

0/10



Nov 2016 - NES outsells PS1 (JP)

Don't Play Stationary 4 ever. Switch!