CGI is what could be described as an ardent fan, or a mature fanboy.
He makes large attempts to control any anti-Microsoft tendencies in his opinions, and too tone down pro-Sony thoughts into the realm of actual possibility. I actually find this to be refreshing and genuine, so he shouldn't take this as an insult at all.
That said, the occasional moments when he oversteps the bounds of those self-imposed structures are largely inconsequential as an ordinary poster. But as a mod, such moments could be quite destructive.
So while I hope CGI will continue to be the entertaining and constructive poster he has become, no, he should not be a mod.