By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming - KillZone2, inFAMOUS, Uncharted 2 > any other 3 exclusives this year

wholikeswood on 15 May 2009

Alan Wake at 96? Wow, that is some confidence.



Around the Network
selnor on 15 May 2009
wholikeswood said:
Alan Wake at 96? Wow, that is some confidence.

Yeah I know. LOL.

Just based off the info and amazing footage of the engine, got a big feeling this will be to horror thriller genre what Halo was to FPS. :)

 



Kantor on 15 May 2009
selnor said:
Kantor said:
selnor said:
Kantor said:
selnor said:
Kantor said:
Sardauk said:
Kantor said:
axumblade said:
Kantor said:
Our bet updated:

PS3:

Killzone 2: 91
MLB 09: The Show: 90
inFamous: 90
Yakuza 3: 84
Singstar Queen: 76

TOTAL: 431

X360:

Could someone else do this? I have no idea what is 2009, and what is exclusive.

Does this count XBLA or DLC?

 

 

6) Games must be proper retail disc games. ODST counts, Peggle does not.

No, it doesn't. Only full retail titles.

 

What is this absurdity supposed to prove ? Another way of telling that the "PS3 is better" by avoiding the sales figures ?

 

This bet is about retail games for both consoles in 2009. I am not saying either console is superior, and I acknowledge that the 360 beats the PS3 every week. What does that have to do with this, exactly?

It's a quality argument. Don't bring sales into it. As for the exclusion of downloadable titles, it's not really fair to give Peggle the same weight as Alan Wake or Uncharted 2, is it?

Yes ODST counts. It is another 10 hour campaign. With more MP content. You have Singstar addon in your list?

Concerning you saying PS3 would possibly beat 360 this year if DLC was counted. I'll take you on a bet with that?

So far it looks like this.

360:

GTA4: Lost And Damned = 90, Peggle = 89, Halo Wars = 82, Fallout 3: Broken Steel = 82, Battlestations Pacific = 77

PS3:

KZ2 = 91, MLB 09: The Show = 90, Flower = 87, Comet Crash = 86, Cuboid = 79

360 = 420

PS3 = 433

 

 

Hmm, so it is winning.

Sorry, no way in hell I'm taking that. I know that XBLA games own PSN games, and Microsoft releases a game on XBLA every week.

And I know ODST counts. That's what I said. It's a retail title, even if it was an hour long campaign with no multiplayer and a map pack, it would be a retail game. If it's download only, with a twenty hour campaign and seventeen multiplayer modes (and a map pack), it wouldn't count. Those were the rules of the bet.

Sorry dude. Thought you meant ODST shouldnt be included. ;)

I understand your point. Last year 360 dominated with DLC scores. Portal etc. To be honest, I think Forza 3, Alan Wake and ODST will all score above 92 Metacritic. They will be what gives the 360 the win in this bet on this thread.

 

I say the top five for 360 would be Alan Wake, Forza 3, ODST, Conviction and Halo Wars.

Top five for PS3 (no order): Uncharted 2, Killzone 2, Crack in Time, GT5, Heavy Rain, all over 90.

Unless Microsoft has a massive 2009 title showing at E3 (unlikely, it'll already be June), I would say I've won this easily.

Thing is for the sake of the bet, I can see Forza 3, Alan Wake and definately ODST all scoring higher than KZ2 Meta. I expect Uncharted 2 to be around 89-90 Meta. Conviction probably will score 89-90. ODST - Meta 94. Alan Wake - 96 Meta ( Got a feeling ) and Forza 3 - 93 Meta. I can see the 360 winning this 5 game bet.

 

I would say:

Alan Wake: 91-96

Forza 3: 87-92

ODST: 89-94

Conviction: 83-88

Halo Wars: 82 (duh)

__________________

Uncharted 2: 89-94

Killzone 2: 91-92

Crack in Time: 88-93

GT5: 89-94

Heavy Rain: 86-91

EDIT: Which is 432-452 for 360

443-464 for PS3.

It'll be close, that's for sure.



(Former) Lead Moderator and (Eternal) VGC Detective

AussieGecko on 15 May 2009
selnor said:

Thing is for the sake of the bet, I can see Forza 3, Alan Wake and definately ODST all scoring higher than KZ2 Meta. I expect Uncharted 2 to be around 89-90 Meta. Conviction probably will score 89-90. ODST - Meta 94. Alan Wake - 96 Meta ( Got a feeling ) and Forza 3 - 93 Meta. I can see the 360 winning this 5 game bet.

 

 

WOO thats the spirit Selnor, GO 360. God infamous is good though lol



 

Bet with Conegamer and Doobie_wop 

http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/post.php?id=3879752

Kantor on 15 May 2009
AussieGecko said:
selnor said:

Thing is for the sake of the bet, I can see Forza 3, Alan Wake and definately ODST all scoring higher than KZ2 Meta. I expect Uncharted 2 to be around 89-90 Meta. Conviction probably will score 89-90. ODST - Meta 94. Alan Wake - 96 Meta ( Got a feeling ) and Forza 3 - 93 Meta. I can see the 360 winning this 5 game bet.

 

 

WOO thats the spirit Selnor, GO 360. God infamous is good though lol

It's on.

Now, get an avatar, so I'll know what to pick when I beat you



(Former) Lead Moderator and (Eternal) VGC Detective

Around the Network
CAL4M1TY on 15 May 2009

Wow this is a really pathetic thread. Oh Well +1 post count for me.

Anyway, clearly those 3 exclusives aren't that great if you must mention them as being the best, it should be common knowledge. No one questioned Super Mario Galaxies greatness and no one brought it up. No one questioned MGS4 awesomeness and no one need to say it out loud.

Do you know the funny thing? It'll most likely be the multiplatform titles that are far superior (not just graphics, EVERYTHING. Which is where I believe KZ2 and Uncharted 2 will lose out. But I hope Uncharted 2 is awesome, with a much better story and AI then the first game) than what the 360 and PS3 will put out this year.

Bioshock 2, Modern Warfare 2 and you can sub in any number of games including wolfenstein/Arkum Asylum/Bionic Commando/Tekken 6/AC 2 etc.

So yes, the PS3 has the better exclusives, But I know at the end of the year, I'll still probably only be playing Infamous and potentially Uncharted 2. What's that saying about the PS3 exclusives (or any exclusives for that matter)? Sure it was fun while it lasted, now what? Oh wait, we're all playing Bioshock 2, Modern Warfare 2, Fifa 10, Fight Night Round 4, Tekken 6.

Funny thing is, at least 90% of those games will sell better on the 360.

Also, you clearly stated any 3 exclusives from MS and Ninty. I believe Nintendo make DS's aswell. So despite your intention to make this about the PS3-Wii-360 you did say any 3 exclusives from either company. The DS has far superior games this year.

Too much ragging on the PS3 in my post. Honestly I hope Uncharted 2 is good, but OP is just ridiculous and I'd be lying if I said I'd be picking any of those 3 (or any 3 360/Wii exclusives EXCEPT maybe Mass Effect 2) over MW2 or Fifa 10 this year in terms of play time (assuming both are as good as the last installment).



Kantor on 15 May 2009
CAL4M1TY said:
Wow this is a really pathetic thread. Oh Well +1 post count for me.

Anyway, clearly those 3 exclusives aren't that great if you must mention them as being the best, it should be common knowledge. No one questioned Super Mario Galaxies greatness and no one brought it up. No one questioned MGS4 awesomeness and no one need to say it out loud.

Do you know the funny thing? It'll most likely be the multiplatform titles that are far superior (not just graphics, EVERYTHING. Which is where I believe KZ2 and Uncharted 2 will lose out. But I hope Uncharted 2 is awesome, with a much better story and AI then the first game) than what the 360 and PS3 will put out this year.

Bioshock 2, Modern Warfare 2 and you can sub in any number of games including wolfenstein/Arkum Asylum/Bionic Commando/Tekken 6/AC 2 etc.

So yes, the PS3 has the better exclusives, But I know at the end of the year, I'll still probably only be playing Infamous and potentially Uncharted 2. What's that saying about the PS3 exclusives (or any exclusives for that matter)? Sure it was fun while it lasted, now what? Oh wait, we're all playing Bioshock 2, Modern Warfare 2, Fifa 10, Fight Night Round 4, Tekken 6.

Funny thing is, at least 90% of those games will sell better on the 360.

Also, you clearly stated any 3 exclusives from MS and Ninty. I believe Nintendo make DS's aswell. So despite your intention to make this about the PS3-Wii-360 you did say any 3 exclusives from either company. The DS has far superior games this year.

Too much ragging on the PS3 in my post. Honestly I hope Uncharted 2 is good, but OP is just ridiculous and I'd be lying if I said I'd be picking any of those 3 (or any 3 360/Wii exclusives EXCEPT maybe Mass Effect 2) over MW2 or Fifa 10 this year in terms of play time (assuming both are as good as the last installment).

You can play those all on PS3, if not exclusively.

I have to agree with you, though. This year is looking to be the best for multiplats in a long time. Last year's multiplats, for the most part, sucked. In fact, this year has great exclusives everywhere (Uncharted 2, Crack in Time, Conviction, Alan Wake, MadWorld, Little King's Story) as well as great multiplats (Modern Warfare 2, Street Fighter IV, BioShock 2, Assassin's Creed 2, etc.)

It also seems to be the year of the number 2



(Former) Lead Moderator and (Eternal) VGC Detective

rckrz6 on 15 May 2009

2 of those 3 games you listed aren;t even out yet. your just judging based on fanboy hype



ameratsu on 15 May 2009

I agree with selnor that if Demon's Souls ever sees a western release, it will get panned by reviewers.

@OP... please stop. I like the ps3's exclusives too, but this sort irrational cheerleading you're doing rubs off on all ps3 fans.



Demon's Souls Official Thread  | Currently playing: Left 4 Dead 2, LittleBigPlanet 2, Magicka

TheSteve on 15 May 2009

Wasn't preordering inFamous supposed ot get me early access to the demo? The download code they gave me is only good after June 6th....



Believing in the PLAYSTATION®3......IS.......S_A_C_R_I_L_E_G_E